Add new figures and update manuscript title, abstract, and keywords

- Added new figures: H30_B29.png, H30_B34.png, H45_B29.png, H45_B34.png, H60_B34.png, H30_29.png, H30_34.png, H45_29.png, H45_34.png, H60_34.png, and updated MethodologyFlowChart.png. - Revised manuscript title to "Damage-aware surrogate optimization of buckling-delayed shear-link dampers with adaptive finite element validation." - Updated abstract to reflect changes in focus and methodology. - Modified keywords for improved relevance. - Enhanced figure descriptions and captions for clarity.
parent ea7fc294
...@@ -7,4 +7,4 @@ tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame ...@@ -7,4 +7,4 @@ tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame
18.64,13.8,0.024436,0.0814959,0.1546975,36.5113,106.3158,107.9247 18.64,13.8,0.024436,0.0814959,0.1546975,36.5113,106.3158,107.9247
13.46,20.99,0.053643,0.0293971,0.1016962,105.4959,49.82,83.5084 13.46,20.99,0.053643,0.0293971,0.1016962,105.4959,49.82,83.5084
8.58,8.88,0.0632531,0.1042515,0.130283,123.1308,165.6866,86.976 8.58,8.88,0.0632531,0.1042515,0.130283,123.1308,165.6866,86.976
12.66,14.7,0.0449044,0.0617909,0.1170024,88.4725,91.4326,88.0453 12.6,14.64,0.0450078,0.0615972,0.1161667,88.2463,91.1868,87.1722
...@@ -7,3 +7,4 @@ tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame ...@@ -7,3 +7,4 @@ tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame
18.64,13.8,0.0302939,0.1027169,0.1913927,44.3285,142.8628,125.6498 18.64,13.8,0.0302939,0.1027169,0.1913927,44.3285,142.8628,125.6498
13.46,20.99,0.0686057,0.033276,0.1173378,138.993,60.5905,89.5536 13.46,20.99,0.0686057,0.033276,0.1173378,138.993,60.5905,89.5536
8.58,8.88,0.1085222,0.1382075,0.1669545,146.7474,192.9294,94.6607 8.58,8.88,0.1085222,0.1382075,0.1669545,146.7474,192.9294,94.6607
15.69,20,0.0512725,0.0460312,0.141023,103.5087,73.2362,99.2099
tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame
15.22,18.46,0.0392701,0.0444714,0.1191054,73.5564,63.4273,88.8872 15.22,18.46,0.0392701,0.0444714,0.1191054,73.5564,63.4273,88.8872
12.74,12.61,0.0401210,0.0783297,0.1249457,72.9956,112.404,93.3510 12.74,12.61,0.040121,0.0783297,0.1249457,72.9956,112.404,93.351
18.03,11.30,0.0227754,0.0992588,0.1671307,35.5244,145.9917,115.5385 18.03,11.3,0.0227754,0.0992588,0.1671307,35.5244,145.9917,115.5385
21.19,19.38,0.0201374,0.0506448,0.1515350,40.3906,70.2570,102.5168 21.19,19.38,0.0201374,0.0506448,0.151535,40.3906,70.257,102.5168
9.78,15.96,0.0710369,0.0433733,0.1167672,143.7781,74.3999,80.5918 9.78,15.96,0.0710369,0.0433733,0.1167672,143.7781,74.3999,80.5918
18.64,13.8,0.0244360,0.0814959,0.1546975,36.5113,106.3158,107.9247 18.64,13.8,0.024436,0.0814959,0.1546975,36.5113,106.3158,107.9247
13.46,20.99,0.0536430,0.0293971,0.1016962,105.4959,49.8200,83.5084 13.46,20.99,0.053643,0.0293971,0.1016962,105.4959,49.82,83.5084
8.58,8.88,0.0632531,0.1042515,0.1302830,123.1308,165.6866,86.9760 8.58,8.88,0.0632531,0.1042515,0.130283,123.1308,165.6866,86.976
12.34,14.34,0.0461157,0.0635088,0.1160707,90.9982,94.5993,87.6823 12.34,14.34,0.0461157,0.0635088,0.1160707,90.9982,94.5993,87.6823
12.68,14.91,0.0449853,0.0597997,0.115753,88.7433,88.8361,86.8080
...@@ -2,9 +2,10 @@ tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame ...@@ -2,9 +2,10 @@ tw1,tw2,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_frame
15.22,18.46,0.0510256,0.0539798,0.1449565,100.9598,83.4741,99.2565 15.22,18.46,0.0510256,0.0539798,0.1449565,100.9598,83.4741,99.2565
12.74,12.61,0.0625263,0.0940645,0.1555176,93.4107,143.0323,105.1522 12.74,12.61,0.0625263,0.0940645,0.1555176,93.4107,143.0323,105.1522
18.03,11.3,0.0295755,0.1281388,0.2320882,41.7941,188.8763,133.5331 18.03,11.3,0.0295755,0.1281388,0.2320882,41.7941,188.8763,133.5331
21.19,19.38,0.0349424,0.0675929,0.1833217,50.9109,88.8950,118.7431 21.19,19.38,0.0349424,0.0675929,0.1833217,50.9109,88.895,118.7431
9.78,15.96,0.0989222,0.0506776,0.1337613,180.2326,82.7747,91.5803 9.78,15.96,0.0989222,0.0506776,0.1337613,180.2326,82.7747,91.5803
18.64,13.8,0.0302939,0.1027169,0.1913927,44.3285,142.8628,125.6498 18.64,13.8,0.0302939,0.1027169,0.1913927,44.3285,142.8628,125.6498
13.46,20.99,0.0686057,0.0332760,0.1173378,138.9930,60.5905,89.5536 13.46,20.99,0.0686057,0.033276,0.1173378,138.993,60.5905,89.5536
8.58,8.88,0.1085222,0.1382075,0.1669545,146.7474,192.9294,94.6607 8.58,8.88,0.1085222,0.1382075,0.1669545,146.7474,192.9294,94.6607
15.50,20.00,0.0521125,0.0454009,0.1396136,105.8219,72.7413,98.4961 15.5,20,0.0521125,0.0454009,0.1396136,105.8219,72.7413,98.4961
14.8,18.93,0.0537676,0.0493064,0.1387399,109.1427,78.7074,96.7782
...@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFM ...@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFM
7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0199412,0.030974,0.1744638,0.2911736,31.3565,37.3897,285.5494,166.6332 7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0199412,0.030974,0.1744638,0.2911736,31.3565,37.3897,285.5494,166.6332
11.94,14.8,15.93,0.0162564,0.0280608,0.0349907,0.0939799,25.3627,48.0349,62.0809,72.4997 11.94,14.8,15.93,0.0162564,0.0280608,0.0349907,0.0939799,25.3627,48.0349,62.0809,72.4997
9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0092622,0.0285342,0.1633582,0.2867144,11.1527,44.1879,260.5004,156.512 9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0092622,0.0285342,0.1633582,0.2867144,11.1527,44.1879,260.5004,156.512
5.52,8.47,9.33,0.0538202,0.0475062,0.0510451,0.098339,102.5485,83.3491,82.8637,67.9344 5.96,8.23,9.47,0.0463678,0.0464775,0.0513613,0.1005854,89.1983,85.2212,83.9612,68.0786
5.81,8.12,9.04,0.0474045,0.0462994,0.0542192,0.100775,91.138,85.5144,88.6423,69.5669 5.81,8.12,9.04,0.0474045,0.0462994,0.0542192,0.100775,91.138,85.5144,88.6423,69.5669
5.53,7.96,8.84,0.0514931,0.0484667,0.0543194,0.1001148,98.0415,88.6742,90.1816,68.8582 5.53,7.96,8.84,0.0514931,0.0484667,0.0543194,0.1001148,98.0415,88.6742,90.1816,68.8582
5.83,7.89,8.95,0.0465888,0.0478258,0.054548,0.1018059,89.3979,88.5887,90.4094,69.1392 5.83,7.89,8.95,0.0465888,0.0478258,0.054548,0.1018059,89.3979,88.5887,90.4094,69.1392
...@@ -15,6 +15,6 @@ tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFM ...@@ -15,6 +15,6 @@ tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFM
7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0205172,0.0282205,0.1826803,0.28507,40.8943,38.3046,285.025,149.7966 7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0205172,0.0282205,0.1826803,0.28507,40.8943,38.3046,285.025,149.7966
11.94,14.8,15.93,0.0239298,0.0817664,0.0338733,0.1028892,42.4723,87.8776,64.2093,69.8335 11.94,14.8,15.93,0.0239298,0.0817664,0.0338733,0.1028892,42.4723,87.8776,64.2093,69.8335
9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0089586,0.032101,0.1749998,0.3156683,13.1979,47.4165,266.644,147.5593 9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0089586,0.032101,0.1749998,0.3156683,13.1979,47.4165,266.644,147.5593
7.39,9.31,10.15,0.0379502,0.0469769,0.053119,0.0937488,79.7768,86.3154,87.0519,69.8441 7.34,9.28,10.13,0.0383401,0.0470196,0.0529832,0.0937131,80.7634,86.7811,87.0794,69.6596
6.88,9.05,9.83,0.0425174,0.0431259,0.0541058,0.0920949,89.8694,89.8644,88.4408,68.6215 6.88,9.05,9.83,0.0425174,0.0431259,0.0541058,0.0920949,89.8694,89.8644,88.4408,68.6215
6.83,9.03,9.71,0.0422012,0.0464421,0.0538225,0.092772,90.4471,89.198,89.9087,68.9794 6.83,9.03,9.71,0.0422012,0.0464421,0.0538225,0.092772,90.4471,89.198,89.9087,68.9794
tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_tw3,TFMmax_frame tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_tw3,TFMmax_frame
8.93,10.69,11.92,0.0246997,0.0417768,0.0464886,0.1013018,42.8515,55.8740,68.8582,72.3628 8.93,10.69,11.92,0.0246997,0.0417768,0.0464886,0.1013018,42.8515,55.874,68.8582,72.3628
14.65,7.11,11.38,0.0027074,0.0739921,0.0456774,0.1320175,3.2259,113.0944,74.3599,81.7340 14.65,7.11,11.38,0.0027074,0.0739921,0.0456774,0.1320175,3.2259,113.0944,74.3599,81.734
6.29,6.52,9.56,0.0400088,0.0663047,0.0487848,0.1169582,74.9831,119.2527,87.0856,69.9576 6.29,6.52,9.56,0.0400088,0.0663047,0.0487848,0.1169582,74.9831,119.2527,87.0856,69.9576
4.58,8.02,12.59,0.0837647,0.0655233,0.0305480,0.0898686,157.3271,109.3948,50.2318,58.5561 4.58,8.02,12.59,0.0837647,0.0655233,0.030548,0.0898686,157.3271,109.3948,50.2318,58.5561
10.95,6.12,10.09,0.0101290,0.0826896,0.0504054,0.1372914,11.6665,133.1484,87.2615,81.9530 10.95,6.12,10.09,0.010129,0.0826896,0.0504054,0.1372914,11.6665,133.1484,87.2615,81.953
13.03,8.96,14.90,0.0072895,0.0609930,0.0302428,0.1157139,8.0061,91.7049,50.4625,79.2896 13.03,8.96,14.9,0.0072895,0.060993,0.0302428,0.1157139,8.0061,91.7049,50.4625,79.2896
15.45,11.10,6.67,0.0024481,0.0291431,0.1215571,0.2017346,0.6759,50.1750,190.3621,126.9695 15.45,11.1,6.67,0.0024481,0.0291431,0.1215571,0.2017346,0.6759,50.175,190.3621,126.9695
14.25,13.56,5.60,0.0020784,0.0282992,0.1565546,0.2872795,1.0843,44.4171,247.7598,155.7495 14.25,13.56,5.6,0.0020784,0.0282992,0.1565546,0.2872795,1.0843,44.4171,247.7598,155.7495
5.22,14.05,8.76,0.0602599,0.0185185,0.0612920,0.1309323,125.8713,32.7268,111.9502,90.7167 5.22,14.05,8.76,0.0602599,0.0185185,0.061292,0.1309323,125.8713,32.7268,111.9502,90.7167
12.69,4.24,7.49,0.0093316,0.1332601,0.1120888,0.1370617,6.2487,206.6610,123.4632,79.5508 12.69,4.24,7.49,0.0093316,0.1332601,0.1120888,0.1370617,6.2487,206.661,123.4632,79.5508
7.82,9.84,14.42,0.0344974,0.0463493,0.0297139,0.0968073,64.2934,77.0343,49.7950,67.3378 7.82,9.84,14.42,0.0344974,0.0463493,0.0297139,0.0968073,64.2934,77.0343,49.795,67.3378
5.72,11.78,13.37,0.0586680,0.0349843,0.0311180,0.0795838,121.0071,55.9826,53.3913,57.7322 5.72,11.78,13.37,0.058668,0.0349843,0.031118,0.0795838,121.0071,55.9826,53.3913,57.7322
10.54,4.85,8.21,0.0178929,0.1071379,0.0903543,0.1374885,13.2657,171.3972,112.4605,79.8828 10.54,4.85,8.21,0.0178929,0.1071379,0.0903543,0.1374885,13.2657,171.3972,112.4605,79.8828
7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0199412,0.0309740,0.1744638,0.2911736,31.3565,37.3897,285.5494,166.6332 7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0199412,0.030974,0.1744638,0.2911736,31.3565,37.3897,285.5494,166.6332
11.94,14.80,15.93,0.0162564,0.0280608,0.0349907,0.0939799,25.3627,48.0349,62.0809,72.4997 11.94,14.8,15.93,0.0162564,0.0280608,0.0349907,0.0939799,25.3627,48.0349,62.0809,72.4997
9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0092622,0.0285342,0.1633582,0.2867144,11.1527,44.1879,260.5004,156.5120 9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0092622,0.0285342,0.1633582,0.2867144,11.1527,44.1879,260.5004,156.512
5.94,8.38,9.28,0.0463239,0.0448421,0.0532387,0.1007058,89.2364,82.0068,85.7161,69.8185 5.94,8.38,9.28,0.0463239,0.0448421,0.0532387,0.1007058,89.2364,82.0068,85.7161,69.8185
5.68,7.97,9.00,0.0493762,0.0478416,0.0536288,0.1003415,94.4223,88.5502,88.8948,68.5487 5.69,7.97,9.02,0.0492756,0.0478664,0.0534413,0.1004192,94.16882,88.57847,88.69432,68.470374
tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_tw3,TFMmax_frame tw1,tw2,tw3,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Eyymax_tf,TFMmax_tw1,TFMmax_tw2,TFMmax_tw3,TFMmax_frame
8.93,10.69,11.92,0.0314285,0.0361880,0.0500572,0.0968860,60.3168,73.0743,75.1730,70.8353 8.93,10.69,11.92,0.0314285,0.036188,0.0500572,0.096886,60.3168,73.0743,75.173,70.8353
14.65,7.11,11.38,0.0041545,0.0770628,0.0446173,0.1298872,5.7242,140.3068,76.6369,85.1589 14.65,7.11,11.38,0.0041545,0.0770628,0.0446173,0.1298872,5.7242,140.3068,76.6369,85.1589
6.29,6.52,9.56,0.0425330,0.0678026,0.0470426,0.1058771,91.4702,145.2878,86.7668,68.0555 6.29,6.52,9.56,0.042533,0.0678026,0.0470426,0.1058771,91.4702,145.2878,86.7668,68.0555
4.58,8.02,12.59,0.1047867,0.0870891,0.0314758,0.0834590,202.6256,124.2751,48.3992,57.2506 4.58,8.02,12.59,0.1047867,0.0870891,0.0314758,0.083459,202.6256,124.2751,48.3992,57.2506
10.95,6.12,10.09,0.0169834,0.0839863,0.0570973,0.1329752,18.5951,160.5635,88.2842,83.5555 10.95,6.12,10.09,0.0169834,0.0839863,0.0570973,0.1329752,18.5951,160.5635,88.2842,83.5555
13.03,8.96,14.90,0.0109994,0.0652393,0.0298515,0.1160830,14.5435,117.7404,55.5012,82.8776 13.03,8.96,14.9,0.0109994,0.0652393,0.0298515,0.116083,14.5435,117.7404,55.5012,82.8776
15.45,11.10,6.67,0.0018370,0.0306984,0.1385195,0.2498688,1.1291,55.9504,197.4358,125.0097 15.45,11.1,6.67,0.001837,0.0306984,0.1385195,0.2498688,1.1291,55.9504,197.4358,125.0097
14.25,13.56,5.60,0.0018503,0.0320090,0.1733572,0.3333523,0.8401,48.5556,257.8822,152.0872 14.25,13.56,5.6,0.0018503,0.032009,0.1733572,0.3333523,0.8401,48.5556,257.8822,152.0872
5.22,14.05,8.76,0.0767186,0.0184562,0.0625321,0.1078929,170.6635,33.4413,105.7267,80.4824 5.22,14.05,8.76,0.0767186,0.0184562,0.0625321,0.1078929,170.6635,33.4413,105.7267,80.4824
12.69,4.24,7.49,0.0087924,0.1325386,0.1181118,0.1384105,9.2216,229.5643,119.7812,81.6469 12.69,4.24,7.49,0.0087924,0.1325386,0.1181118,0.1384105,9.2216,229.5643,119.7812,81.6469
7.82,9.84,14.42,0.0421770,0.0474820,0.0297936,0.0934205,88.3429,98.3484,53.4841,67.0666 7.82,9.84,14.42,0.042177,0.047482,0.0297936,0.0934205,88.3429,98.3484,53.4841,67.0666
5.72,11.78,13.37,0.0772789,0.0353789,0.0293972,0.0719482,166.3376,67.8034,55.0039,54.5020 5.72,11.78,13.37,0.0772789,0.0353789,0.0293972,0.0719482,166.3376,67.8034,55.0039,54.502
10.54,4.85,8.21,0.0161377,0.1107135,0.0903302,0.1383831,18.5385,195.3177,110.0121,81.7428 10.54,4.85,8.21,0.0161377,0.1107135,0.0903302,0.1383831,18.5385,195.3177,110.0121,81.7428
7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0205172,0.0282205,0.1826803,0.2850700,40.8943,38.3046,285.0250,149.7966 7.07,15.26,4.16,0.0205172,0.0282205,0.1826803,0.28507,40.8943,38.3046,285.025,149.7966
11.94,14.80,15.93,0.0239298,0.0817664,0.0338733,0.1028892,42.4723,87.8776,64.2093,69.8335 11.94,14.8,15.93,0.0239298,0.0817664,0.0338733,0.1028892,42.4723,87.8776,64.2093,69.8335
9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0089586,0.0321010,0.1749998,0.3156683,13.1979,47.4165,266.6440,147.5593 9.81,12.65,4.96,0.0089586,0.032101,0.1749998,0.3156683,13.1979,47.4165,266.644,147.5593
7.21,9.27,9.82,0.0389181,0.0460074,0.0552465,0.0930625,82.2030,85.0636,90.3346,70.8627 7.21,9.27,9.82,0.0389181,0.0460074,0.0552465,0.0930625,82.203,85.0636,90.3346,70.8627
6.81,9.02,9.65,0.042284433,0.046292119,0.054206595,0.092638396,90.54817,89.06076492,90.38183775,69.0909405
...@@ -63,6 +63,6 @@ tw1,tw2,tw3,tw4,tw5,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Exymax_tw4,Exymax_tw5,Eyyma ...@@ -63,6 +63,6 @@ tw1,tw2,tw3,tw4,tw5,Exymax_tw1,Exymax_tw2,Exymax_tw3,Exymax_tw4,Exymax_tw5,Eyyma
10.08,13.19,12.66,9.43,12.79,0.0182058,0.0173443,0.0443796,0.0671675,0.0281014,0.1455139,27.9228,26.9374,63.7859,95.6849,54.3139,93.6209 10.08,13.19,12.66,9.43,12.79,0.0182058,0.0173443,0.0443796,0.0671675,0.0281014,0.1455139,27.9228,26.9374,63.7859,95.6849,54.3139,93.6209
8.96,4.52,5.58,6.91,9.82,0.0182504,0.0894588,0.1212475,0.0631662,0.024132,0.1199809,21.3667,157.3141,204.0845,99.8104,32.8082,61.9136 8.96,4.52,5.58,6.91,9.82,0.0182504,0.0894588,0.1212475,0.0631662,0.024132,0.1199809,21.3667,157.3141,204.0845,99.8104,32.8082,61.9136
5.68,13.91,12.58,11.42,5.93,0.066269,0.0164049,0.0266002,0.0471815,0.0612316,0.1382278,123.0662,24.2749,43.1425,56.6075,108.8461,93.968 5.68,13.91,12.58,11.42,5.93,0.066269,0.0164049,0.0266002,0.0471815,0.0612316,0.1382278,123.0662,24.2749,43.1425,56.6075,108.8461,93.968
5.74,7.35,8.73,6.54,5,0.0616588,0.0548414,0.0568781,0.0715819,0.0582073,0.1218811,93.0957,93.5817,82.9841,81.4939,72.9981,78.5423 5.97,7.38,8.56,6.7,5,0.0563488,0.0518778,0.0596584,0.0712373,0.058239,0.1229254,84.9512,90.6505,87.9108,81.0599,74.1754,79.1536
5.7,7.42,8.45,6.09,5,0.0602438,0.0528245,0.0588412,0.0775535,0.0574888,0.1230745,92.0594,89.7108,87.3874,91.3958,72.3656,77.627 5.7,7.42,8.45,6.09,5,0.0602438,0.0528245,0.0588412,0.0775535,0.0574888,0.1230745,92.0594,89.7108,87.3874,91.3958,72.3656,77.627
5.76,7.39,8.42,6.17,5,0.0581466,0.0520777,0.0593142,0.077353,0.0579703,0.1234245,90.1357,89.9638,88.5223,90.3566,72.4717,77.916 5.76,7.39,8.42,6.17,5,0.0581466,0.0520777,0.0593142,0.077353,0.0579703,0.1234245,90.1357,89.9638,88.5223,90.3566,72.4717,77.916
output,model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,fit_time_sec,gpr_kernel
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.0024756253409925536,0.003162723363436417,1.2775452371837432,0.0024756253409925536,,"{""svr__C"": 1776.5766649807683, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00032780432870046914, ""svr__gamma"": 0.006225026900894044}",16.06,
exymax_tw1,GaussianProcess,0.003544749506220166,0.00339206480908583,0.9569265199511527,0.003544749506220166,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 74.13954798652198, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern52"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.845551297039509, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 1, ""gpr__noise"": 4.912618463633794e-12, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.05514509165905166}",29.56,"2.95**2 * Matern(length_scale=4.58, nu=2.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=4.91e-12)"
exymax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,0.004354007132602834,0.0029001392846239988,0.6660851019070999,0.004354007132602834,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""tanh"", ""mlp__alpha"": 3.278043287004692e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.001570703295827246, ""mlp__n_layers"": 4, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 298}",231.81,
exymax_tw1,GradientBoosting,0.007005089494731147,0.005181425608557407,0.7396658690020446,0.007005089494731147,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1197, ""subsample"": 0.7}",29.94,
exymax_tw1,XGBoost,0.01026511863275899,0.007655666115322084,0.7457942172134883,0.01026511863275899,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.8548914165297054, ""learning_rate"": 0.2, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 1021, ""subsample"": 0.7398023228939841}",24.87,
exymax_tw1,RandomForest,0.013433152778697579,0.007877314928573092,0.5864084968247374,0.013433152778697579,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 0.506420824114914, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 302}",43.26,
exymax_tw2,GaussianProcess,0.0011086563042916073,0.0015044652951971592,1.3570168584920104,0.0011086563042916073,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 1.1678028847340653, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RBF"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 56.93148314584267, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 1.1169777362871868e-11, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.1573413368158819}",28.01,3.47**2 * RBF(length_scale=4.76) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.001835044976721644,0.0015670942703104398,0.8539813956549963,0.001835044976721644,,"{""svr__C"": 1163.9595637448144, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00517350174828139}",17.56,
exymax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,0.007043272559668965,0.004169776509759758,0.5920225966600585,0.007043272559668965,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""tanh"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.0015685758942019072, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0006323708860074323, ""mlp__n_layers"": 1, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 508}",195.69,
exymax_tw2,GradientBoosting,0.011043108784279058,0.010722066983689561,0.9709283131352893,0.011043108784279058,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.023619267887061358, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 0.9644651085727028, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.9}",34.49,
exymax_tw2,XGBoost,0.013884196640337838,0.006516852773533836,0.46937197321164303,0.013884196640337838,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7, ""learning_rate"": 0.2, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.7}",21.45,
exymax_tw2,RandomForest,0.014437022668518516,0.007424862284508211,0.5142931790707044,0.014437022668518516,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200}",34.91,
tfmmax_frame,SVR,2.0080189686021916,1.834503145292003,0.9135885536823514,2.0080189686021916,,"{""svr__C"": 776.8578433766332, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.012846134106856165}",20.4,
tfmmax_frame,GradientBoosting,3.2496602362879483,2.3154490851486,0.7125203611419735,3.2496602362879483,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.7}",38.78,
tfmmax_frame,GaussianProcess,3.2622096940791403,2.327255350491035,0.7133984534209947,3.2622096940791403,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 15.783879853890564, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.2778531518898433, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 1.7014397704982245e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 7.38115974661544}",32.65,"2.48**2 * Matern(length_scale=6.06, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.7e-05)"
tfmmax_frame,XGBoost,4.483676044379338,3.975644078363131,0.8866929811637333,4.483676044379338,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7, ""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1122, ""subsample"": 0.7}",28.14,
tfmmax_frame,RandomForest,5.5303515805555366,4.473703176262174,0.8089364864236679,5.5303515805555366,,"{""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",41.89,
tfmmax_frame,FlexibleMLP,7.3172526519820895,7.04557172093037,0.9628711834928747,7.3172526519820895,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.0006944934206396821, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0032339779426927657, ""mlp__n_layers"": 1, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 99}",304.77,
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,4.3925021654363405,5.5001549209265885,1.252168971982787,4.3925021654363405,,"{""svr__C"": 5236.232200043871, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.1}",21.66,
tfmmax_tw1,GaussianProcess,5.824945633600926,7.686077467608444,1.3195105930726059,5.824945633600926,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 3.040177505329657, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.2629640031365337, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 6.934513810183029e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 6.061391141345191}",40.44,"1.76**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=1e+03, length_scale=2.16) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=6.93e-08)"
tfmmax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,6.582640034090435,6.961591808104234,1.05756835738416,6.582640034090435,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 1e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 64}",259.59,
tfmmax_tw1,GradientBoosting,13.511793024681092,10.764396684203307,0.796666783197515,13.511793024681092,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 895, ""subsample"": 0.7}",35.2,
tfmmax_tw1,XGBoost,22.219134584554038,16.764440739148885,0.7545046669280691,22.219134584554038,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7674077607707166, ""learning_rate"": 0.015555219980438314, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1038, ""subsample"": 0.7}",33.74,
tfmmax_tw1,RandomForest,23.641361117592606,9.94313351385015,0.4205821088046836,23.641361117592606,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200}",40.22,
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,5.680020912182758,5.561050062783906,0.9790545050382337,5.680020912182758,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00963488624259149}",18.34,
tfmmax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,9.087693906694744,8.268052260251366,0.9098075204932285,9.087693906694744,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.009274969483615187, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.006500900236900651, ""mlp__n_layers"": 1, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 115}",361.1,
tfmmax_tw2,GaussianProcess,10.0291035442904,10.021186033768807,0.9992105465372225,10.0291035442904,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 9.00918862493577, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern52"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.2157726626660632, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 0.0001, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 2.141520783739573}",40.02,"3.41**2 * Matern(length_scale=6.41, nu=2.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.01)"
tfmmax_tw2,GradientBoosting,11.598380810221878,10.593068910995997,0.9133230822754259,11.598380810221878,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.06788372479073597, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.7}",33.98,
tfmmax_tw2,RandomForest,17.4599810031348,15.045985293298534,0.8617412178511046,17.4599810031348,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 319}",45.19,
tfmmax_tw2,XGBoost,20.199756171332467,14.78180515090588,0.731781365355501,20.199756171332467,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.035040930870097256, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.7}",27.36,
output,best_model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,model_path,train_time_sec,gpr_kernel,selected_by
exymax_tw2,GaussianProcess,0.0011086563042916073,0.0015044652951971592,1.3570168584920104,0.0011086563042916073,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 1.1678028847340653, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RBF"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 56.93148314584267, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 1.1169777362871868e-11, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.1573413368158819}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H30/it1/best_model_exymax_tw2.joblib,332.1,3.47**2 * RBF(length_scale=4.76) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12),lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.0024756253409925536,0.003162723363436417,1.2775452371837432,0.0024756253409925536,,"{""svr__C"": 1776.5766649807683, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00032780432870046914, ""svr__gamma"": 0.006225026900894044}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H30/it1/best_model_exymax_tw1.joblib,375.5,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_frame,SVR,2.0080189686021916,1.834503145292003,0.9135885536823514,2.0080189686021916,,"{""svr__C"": 776.8578433766332, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.012846134106856165}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H30/it1/best_model_tfmmax_frame.joblib,466.63,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,4.3925021654363405,5.5001549209265885,1.252168971982787,4.3925021654363405,,"{""svr__C"": 5236.232200043871, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.1}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H30/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw1.joblib,430.85,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,5.680020912182758,5.561050062783906,0.9790545050382337,5.680020912182758,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00963488624259149}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H30/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw2.joblib,525.99,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
output,model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,fit_time_sec,gpr_kernel
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.0008570511851203082,0.0006731653127795403,0.7854435353065231,0.0008570511851203082,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.005539382250631029}",15.78,
exymax_tw1,GaussianProcess,0.00259269843299015,0.003052161150710224,1.177214099362176,0.00259269843299015,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 17.76576664980768, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RBF"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 2.467108843522573, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 8, ""gpr__noise"": 1.5290392171324112e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.024089076834871728}",27.84,3.96**2 * RBF(length_scale=4.34) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.53e-08)
exymax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,0.0040100425936702416,0.003920304407185099,0.9776216375789145,0.0040100425936702416,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.00014654496622910706, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0004227157952168497, ""mlp__n_layers"": 4, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 512}",231.54,
exymax_tw1,GradientBoosting,0.0075532811368529225,0.009000714666129126,1.1916297703012915,0.0075532811368529225,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07999999999999999, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 0.6, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.9}",34.17,
exymax_tw1,RandomForest,0.013631267656481476,0.011536827513353016,0.846350303147882,0.013631267656481476,,"{""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 200}",37.11,
exymax_tw1,XGBoost,0.020261089147528014,0.01403886937801257,0.6928980607010163,0.020261089147528014,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7, ""learning_rate"": 0.2, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.95}",20.85,
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.004098427736105821,0.005731658601911444,1.3985018087344538,0.004098427736105821,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.000496625156190818, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00798837332507487}",17.3,
exymax_tw2,GaussianProcess,0.006278008952606092,0.006251443662881164,0.9957685167502189,0.006278008952606092,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 8.632012725909878, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.04512619487621619, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 3, ""gpr__noise"": 2.5352795401259186e-06, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.30925669615839474}",31.46,"4.33**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=1.35, length_scale=5.57) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.00114)"
exymax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,0.010756116204244055,0.007640357174494708,0.7103267600883711,0.010756116204244055,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""tanh"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.01, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0001, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 512}",277.99,
exymax_tw2,GradientBoosting,0.014207767921725052,0.010336192381796545,0.7275029011412487,0.014207767921725052,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07999999999999999, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 507, ""subsample"": 0.7}",28.55,
exymax_tw2,RandomForest,0.0199899622666667,0.014959820626122325,0.7483666265377527,0.0199899622666667,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 200}",35.21,
exymax_tw2,XGBoost,0.02252720948460897,0.01564238317593637,0.6943773123175132,0.02252720948460897,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.8924816362701187, ""learning_rate"": 0.021789610070768725, ""max_depth"": 1, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 238, ""subsample"": 0.7964709521551065}",22.92,
tfmmax_frame,SVR,3.011026789438939,4.004787262164137,1.3300403955922195,3.011026789438939,,"{""svr__C"": 1481.8620538180178, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.008831482506567626}",18.7,
tfmmax_frame,FlexibleMLP,3.4329196927593526,3.5962636880616357,1.047581653496528,3.4329196927593526,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""tanh"", ""mlp__alpha"": 4.133393571577299e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 1, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 249}",1385.2,
tfmmax_frame,GaussianProcess,4.420805377977214,3.215902511990723,0.7274472040798577,4.420805377977214,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 15.302922772649232, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.4082478946247343, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 9, ""gpr__noise"": 0.0001, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 100.0}",33.11,"2.41**2 * Matern(length_scale=5.94, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=9.98e-05)"
tfmmax_frame,GradientBoosting,4.612996940871379,4.84040521061896,1.0492972947223815,4.612996940871379,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.013919589474543723, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 0.6548784763847341, ""n_estimators"": 1376, ""subsample"": 0.7}",36.63,
tfmmax_frame,RandomForest,7.313851344444424,5.386302748414373,0.7364523142114161,7.313851344444424,,"{""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",37.19,
tfmmax_frame,XGBoost,7.802602041286891,4.566311927582524,0.5852293764849499,7.802602041286891,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7, ""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1200, ""subsample"": 0.7}",34.19,
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,4.560302421976251,6.820351469024152,1.4955919230612091,4.560302421976251,,"{""svr__C"": 3379.63611316452, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.019544854457496024}",20.65,
tfmmax_tw1,GaussianProcess,9.105443149658928,10.600553074326331,1.1641995782185963,9.105443149658928,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 5.282502596111938, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.2599580284909435, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 9.78963138858132e-06, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 10.361438545346061}",32.81,"3**2 * Matern(length_scale=7.32, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.72e-09)"
tfmmax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,10.06809365397592,7.534600313824996,0.7483641464588046,10.06809365397592,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.0009867418278990128, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 1, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 64}",273.92,
tfmmax_tw1,GradientBoosting,16.819826032983443,18.5413004600373,1.1023479329499644,16.819826032983443,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.062293187477610465, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 0.8335379521129794, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.7}",41.65,
tfmmax_tw1,RandomForest,28.513960764390934,16.316328891767192,0.5722224641672194,28.513960764390934,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 415}",45.77,
tfmmax_tw1,XGBoost,33.646646844482426,22.338090055573662,0.6639024137775795,33.646646844482426,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.9351802199931738, ""learning_rate"": 0.1923434374313926, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 923, ""subsample"": 0.7862748144930891}",32.73,
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,7.532025741419391,5.994528134314546,0.7958719659373991,7.532025741419391,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.018215310665708}",20.35,
tfmmax_tw2,GaussianProcess,9.4146236263087,8.042905282918047,0.8542991841375949,9.4146236263087,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 22.364202820542708, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.1635461931468242, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 8.185087448430454e-06, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.017752182884113583}",32.97,"3.58**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=1e+03, length_scale=4.31) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.00398)"
tfmmax_tw2,GradientBoosting,13.587370298798847,10.313239200828738,0.7590312896484797,13.587370298798847,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.02911560928746067, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1238, ""subsample"": 0.724603829439197}",34.7,
tfmmax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,13.638150768372547,8.656749417008834,0.6347451032059424,13.638150768372547,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.00834395187014542, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0029488173801534745, ""mlp__n_layers"": 1, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 64}",228.45,
tfmmax_tw2,RandomForest,23.399001751183537,20.62974127884238,0.8816504865554324,23.399001751183537,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 665}",43.46,
tfmmax_tw2,XGBoost,25.95496679280599,19.083915126969973,0.7352702578783308,25.95496679280599,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.95}",23.47,
output,best_model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,model_path,train_time_sec,gpr_kernel,selected_by
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.0008570511851203082,0.0006731653127795403,0.7854435353065231,0.0008570511851203082,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.005539382250631029}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H30/it1/best_model_exymax_tw1.joblib,367.29,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.004098427736105821,0.005731658601911444,1.3985018087344538,0.004098427736105821,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.000496625156190818, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00798837332507487}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H30/it1/best_model_exymax_tw2.joblib,413.43,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_frame,SVR,3.011026789438939,4.004787262164137,1.3300403955922195,3.011026789438939,,"{""svr__C"": 1481.8620538180178, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.008831482506567626}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H30/it1/best_model_tfmmax_frame.joblib,1545.02,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,4.560302421976251,6.820351469024152,1.4955919230612091,4.560302421976251,,"{""svr__C"": 3379.63611316452, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.019544854457496024}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H30/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw1.joblib,447.54,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,7.532025741419391,5.994528134314546,0.7958719659373991,7.532025741419391,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.018215310665708}",../../models/width_optimization/2W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H30/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw2.joblib,383.42,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
output,LOO_RMSE,LOO_MAE,LOO_R2,LOO_RMSE_STD,LOO_RMSE_CV,LOO_MAE_STD,LOO_SQERR_STD
exymax_tw1,0.007812656716947588,0.004826234538342722,0.7670274266915268,0.006143701258832014,1.2729802520002882,0.006143701258832014,0.00014033396207694654
exymax_tw2,0.008480493911263634,0.005499651414187815,0.8705129954974506,0.006455432696682816,1.173789429640815,0.006455432696682816,0.00014803756335460616
tfmmax_tw1,11.12196967900263,6.833950421315495,0.8993653836220409,8.774698352630454,1.283986246850965,8.774698352630454,305.00229159317195
tfmmax_tw2,13.365853767161791,11.075408982373931,0.852276168131844,7.4820694195058,0.6755569416364862,7.4820694195058,197.56647120129273
tfmmax_frame,12.511912820841165,7.144775543417528,-0.3223437947375569,10.271326344270843,1.4375995833394377,10.271326344270843,331.43515599253226
output,LOO_RMSE,LOO_MAE,LOO_R2,LOO_RMSE_STD,LOO_RMSE_CV,LOO_MAE_STD,LOO_SQERR_STD
exymax_tw1,0.0069907606781344665,0.005219312215888287,0.9254785518802771,0.004650754223997476,0.8910664914507234,0.004650754223997476,6.505482746800609e-05
exymax_tw2,0.009470178673517972,0.006266140744947335,0.9270752905067744,0.007100687591555164,1.1331835463926918,0.007100687591555164,0.00012828248176948906
tfmmax_tw1,16.044573039703014,10.510325581437282,0.8658292341548922,12.122762894594198,1.1534145922182188,12.122762894594198,396.04809773092245
tfmmax_tw2,12.508458205945779,8.640986797730678,0.9283835926458075,9.044051849217606,1.0466457200921522,9.044051849217606,234.35307303644234
tfmmax_frame,15.554012347205763,7.828592348187034,-0.15381669651958507,13.440254534157333,1.716816246955286,13.440254534157333,628.8875343934393
output,model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,fit_time_sec,gpr_kernel
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.004544565096969737,0.005622030813647301,1.2370888508992874,0.004544565096969737,,"{""svr__C"": 2.0969470732826045, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00010027088895761322, ""svr__gamma"": 0.03663137264354234}",17.92,
exymax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,0.0050412677729353384,0.005583817422831337,1.1076216686621454,0.0050412677729353384,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""tanh"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.00923655338702395, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.007516853847204845, ""mlp__n_layers"": 2, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 123}",385.41,
exymax_tw1,GaussianProcess,0.0059238977582803855,0.006595334052775796,1.113343666939032,0.0059238977582803855,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 15.783879853890564, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.2778531518898433, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 1.7014397704982245e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 7.38115974661544}",31.58,"1.56**2 * Matern(length_scale=3.36, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.7e-05)"
exymax_tw1,GradientBoosting,0.006366275813505121,0.006783848825448715,1.0655914107676223,0.006366275813505121,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.0710424418691191, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 0.9968580993343699, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.8494010383216993}",35.45,
exymax_tw1,XGBoost,0.00883425397652475,0.010149621343495339,1.1488939949503278,0.00883425397652475,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""min_child_weight"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 862, ""subsample"": 0.7}",26.54,
exymax_tw1,RandomForest,0.009197296698506052,0.007921215100538245,0.8612547099654744,0.009197296698506052,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 800}",50.25,
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.007153056583588979,0.0048896483167959436,0.6835746732402623,0.007153056583588979,,"{""svr__C"": 1578.3879853890564, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.002061045404501547, ""svr__gamma"": 0.003800674800490907}",17.44,
exymax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,0.008236601439844313,0.007159647932692601,0.8692478305503551,0.008236601439844313,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 1e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0015082948374470805, ""mlp__n_layers"": 4, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 447}",504.57,
exymax_tw2,GaussianProcess,0.009003319801309043,0.005790670916025819,0.6431706352565507,0.009003319801309043,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 97.94964542124627, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 100.0, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 6.630395769645683e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 44.03156348852136}",27.44,"1.9**2 * Matern(length_scale=4.29, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)"
exymax_tw2,GradientBoosting,0.009844471479160443,0.00847474078861905,0.8608629530350159,0.009844471479160443,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.06731961345185845, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 0.9811986645112635, ""n_estimators"": 274, ""subsample"": 0.7145322799410668}",42.35,
exymax_tw2,RandomForest,0.010509609865327067,0.012130908465813654,1.154268200367315,0.010509609865327067,,"{""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 686}",52.38,
exymax_tw2,XGBoost,0.011738357719494314,0.013775972278520768,1.1735859996533002,0.011738357719494314,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.980870361862916, ""learning_rate"": 0.082181215369422, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 385, ""subsample"": 0.8666741271367171}",24.31,
exymax_tw3,GradientBoosting,0.006016570757245166,0.005743412757159203,0.9545990546596622,0.006016570757245166,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.05158453956497575, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.8337045824403948}",37.81,
exymax_tw3,SVR,0.006591557343857968,0.004646214393113682,0.704873545163502,0.006591557343857968,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.0019004530265430027}",16.69,
exymax_tw3,GaussianProcess,0.00846522658962886,0.007454371415901467,0.8805873460060906,0.00846522658962886,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 100.0, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.25476525846625475, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 1.300248619700011e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.10574394317144024}",30.91,"2.61**2 * Matern(length_scale=7.37, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)"
exymax_tw3,RandomForest,0.011376479509372081,0.009818012033779735,0.8630096881633319,0.011376479509372081,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",49.19,
exymax_tw3,FlexibleMLP,0.011635115499089476,0.009993219084346168,0.8588843905441422,0.011635115499089476,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.007407252913290957, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.002363991255511292, ""mlp__n_layers"": 4, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 142}",230.39,
exymax_tw3,XGBoost,0.014033108898523276,0.015072348176407237,1.0740562398110745,0.014033108898523276,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.2, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1200, ""subsample"": 0.95}",24.2,
tfmmax_frame,SVR,2.0392791608860255,2.0486984258782583,1.0046189188674592,2.0392791608860255,,"{""svr__C"": 551.6615876649848, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.07028818985152292}",22.19,
tfmmax_frame,GaussianProcess,2.9436104947010318,2.1695494679837415,0.7370368708391536,2.9436104947010318,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 100.0, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 100.0, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 0.0001, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.01}",36.06,"1.28**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=1e+03, length_scale=2.52) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.000586)"
tfmmax_frame,FlexibleMLP,8.439433068964945,5.974847417326105,0.7079678656731014,8.439433068964945,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 1.3836782850937756e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.005091702207747155, ""mlp__n_layers"": 1, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 449}",1093.16,
tfmmax_frame,GradientBoosting,8.711715787738814,8.00699131867442,0.9191061225784879,8.711715787738814,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.06842804697785465, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1421, ""subsample"": 0.7014608136413895}",42.31,
tfmmax_frame,XGBoost,11.364511135325714,14.485676518032047,1.2746414118073615,11.364511135325714,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7, ""learning_rate"": 0.0346980632957602, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.95}",30.84,
tfmmax_frame,RandomForest,11.596480403221278,8.664861275330887,0.747197509420527,11.596480403221278,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",48.66,
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,7.542695824409187,10.800933259893343,1.4319725349310861,7.542695824409187,,"{""svr__C"": 666.0814900036285, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.1}",23.73,
tfmmax_tw1,GaussianProcess,8.029824980093872,11.684012971725563,1.4550769164571469,8.029824980093872,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 100.0, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 3.1792120780075597, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 0.0001, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 17.960291580114607}",32.73,"2.23**2 * Matern(length_scale=5.33, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.77e-08)"
tfmmax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,8.985199982616617,10.87966430685878,1.210842755632298,8.985199982616617,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 3.491272406900459e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0002730247960373466, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 473}",866.71,
tfmmax_tw1,GradientBoosting,11.1005724512462,9.712332774355945,0.8749398120693852,11.1005724512462,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07999999999999999, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 0.9651557408069895, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.7}",36.56,
tfmmax_tw1,XGBoost,16.10165685674443,18.065752793127494,1.121980983314793,16.10165685674443,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.01585121486637115, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 386, ""subsample"": 0.7}",26.49,
tfmmax_tw1,RandomForest,19.651220877565326,15.383786063867792,0.782841237178835,19.651220877565326,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 0.970019289317713, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 800}",63.65,
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,6.959305590142771,5.588544761719235,0.8030319533079429,6.959305590142771,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.04637768497983556}",25.57,
tfmmax_tw2,GaussianProcess,7.475551172119426,5.378969123003344,0.7195414758265014,7.475551172119426,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 17.95581563154738, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RBF"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 2.9824264558361286, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 8, ""gpr__noise"": 6.503681480336127e-10, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.01}",35.85,2.91**2 * RBF(length_scale=3.1) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=6.5e-10)
tfmmax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,8.656458919718622,8.082172311071895,0.9336580218340141,8.656458919718622,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.00022389985002234367, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 3, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 346}",561.46,
tfmmax_tw2,GradientBoosting,10.52753781109614,11.597200253851943,1.1016061363967145,10.52753781109614,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.059904198883548275, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 271, ""subsample"": 0.7}",37.71,
tfmmax_tw2,XGBoost,11.263636317354088,11.364972024650141,1.0089967133562296,11.263636317354088,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.16120695138256938, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1200, ""subsample"": 0.7}",33.48,
tfmmax_tw2,RandomForest,18.615390744650394,19.293710069425988,1.0364386294158519,18.615390744650394,,"{""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 8, ""n_estimators"": 265}",58.39,
tfmmax_tw3,SVR,4.618428678644538,4.71572163761625,1.0210662469297387,4.618428678644538,,"{""svr__C"": 4960.755063873588, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.03679842296848954}",24.39,
tfmmax_tw3,FlexibleMLP,6.295836400213605,7.812494214954995,1.2408985428353783,6.295836400213605,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 1e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0011635165631175464, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 512}",1437.46,
tfmmax_tw3,GaussianProcess,7.6404119705562925,9.012541156698584,1.1795883770966853,7.6404119705562925,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 20.481779258751512, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.4450186087390031, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 6.497442689729577e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 28.94596043054653}",34.76,"3.17**2 * Matern(length_scale=10.7, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=4.61e-10)"
tfmmax_tw3,GradientBoosting,7.995038420951784,7.451197566125652,0.93197770589808,7.995038420951784,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.04808451650213672, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.7}",43.39,
tfmmax_tw3,RandomForest,15.926523986589647,16.847221149370895,1.0578090463152217,15.926523986589647,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",46.67,
tfmmax_tw3,XGBoost,21.854043632597083,24.01399985830991,1.0988355410113246,21.854043632597083,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1200, ""subsample"": 0.7}",32.63,
output,best_model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,model_path,train_time_sec,gpr_kernel,selected_by
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.004544565096969737,0.005622030813647301,1.2370888508992874,0.004544565096969737,,"{""svr__C"": 2.0969470732826045, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00010027088895761322, ""svr__gamma"": 0.03663137264354234}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H45/it1/best_model_exymax_tw1.joblib,547.14,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw3,GradientBoosting,0.006016570757245166,0.005743412757159203,0.9545990546596622,0.006016570757245166,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.05158453956497575, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.8337045824403948}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H45/it1/best_model_exymax_tw3.joblib,389.25,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.007153056583588979,0.0048896483167959436,0.6835746732402623,0.007153056583588979,,"{""svr__C"": 1578.3879853890564, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.002061045404501547, ""svr__gamma"": 0.003800674800490907}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H45/it1/best_model_exymax_tw2.joblib,668.5,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_frame,SVR,2.0392791608860255,2.0486984258782583,1.0046189188674592,2.0392791608860255,,"{""svr__C"": 551.6615876649848, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.07028818985152292}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_frame.joblib,1273.23,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw3,SVR,4.618428678644538,4.71572163761625,1.0210662469297387,4.618428678644538,,"{""svr__C"": 4960.755063873588, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.03679842296848954}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw3.joblib,1619.29,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,6.959305590142771,5.588544761719235,0.8030319533079429,6.959305590142771,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.04637768497983556}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw2.joblib,752.48,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,7.542695824409187,10.800933259893343,1.4319725349310861,7.542695824409187,,"{""svr__C"": 666.0814900036285, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.1}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B29_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw1.joblib,1049.88,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
output,model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,fit_time_sec,gpr_kernel
exymax_tw1,GradientBoosting,0.006809025144747611,0.009611717846807024,1.4116143856835912,0.006809025144747611,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07917979609766448, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 0.8923682916293771, ""n_estimators"": 1467, ""subsample"": 0.7010466119809067}",38.25,
exymax_tw1,GaussianProcess,0.008469174359771448,0.009446026401124477,1.1153420628571626,0.008469174359771448,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 15.783879853890564, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.2778531518898433, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 1.7014397704982245e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 7.38115974661544}",29.49,"1.68**2 * Matern(length_scale=3.37, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.7e-05)"
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.009345554423643853,0.009858738024440938,1.0549120552440154,0.009345554423643853,,"{""svr__C"": 1.9459673128256836, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.003789524241346744, ""svr__gamma"": 0.03938242797703584}",16.05,
exymax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,0.010417105745014674,0.009958498797248845,0.9559755887103953,0.010417105745014674,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.002841123150877317, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0030378441442185035, ""mlp__n_layers"": 2, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 323}",398.66,
exymax_tw1,RandomForest,0.010579458288397464,0.010332710876409952,0.9766767441903788,0.010579458288397464,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 471}",50.07,
exymax_tw1,XGBoost,0.014146841736031215,0.014640946336809136,1.034926848691568,0.014146841736031215,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.8369227114969269, ""learning_rate"": 0.041005535247050494, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.7506268224237105}",24.35,
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.00930805333,0.01190469458692915,1.2789671658369355,0.00930805333,,"{""svr__C"": 1776.5766649807683, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00032780432870046914, ""svr__gamma"": 0.006225026900894044}",15.3,
exymax_tw2,GradientBoosting,0.010661774631702066,0.011892424542842138,1.1154263669652908,0.010661774631702066,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07956219027083677, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 0.8702236524428513, ""n_estimators"": 1466, ""subsample"": 0.7131619449245821}",38.61,
exymax_tw2,GaussianProcess,0.011672418594352859,0.010390764518246286,0.8901980711412595,0.011672418594352859,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.791104329380143, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RBF"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.01, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 4.526738948948404e-12, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.2911260684256326}",31.07,1.02**2 * RBF(length_scale=1.28) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)
exymax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,0.01174318142457347,0.008945373963883611,0.7617504695247881,0.01174318142457347,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 6.028650173490873e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.008859791225565603, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 353}",415.35,
exymax_tw2,RandomForest,0.015554543972288903,0.014994424673330854,0.9639899890375491,0.015554543972288903,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 420}",45.65,
exymax_tw2,XGBoost,0.01672503280468969,0.012581178136321714,0.7522363802356166,0.01672503280468969,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.9674240969866565, ""learning_rate"": 0.16730141290526662, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 200, ""subsample"": 0.8876489097706326}",30.33,
exymax_tw3,GradientBoosting,0.0064598099969471285,0.004886210506349151,0.7564015828110034,0.0064598099969471285,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07999999999999999, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1500, ""subsample"": 0.8985849113780995}",37.38,
exymax_tw3,SVR,0.006722135111899321,0.003892543347026375,0.5790635389246955,0.006722135111899321,,"{""svr__C"": 9213.884743379953, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00010269561801572416, ""svr__gamma"": 0.0008423186569242777}",19.37,
exymax_tw3,GaussianProcess,0.008691576274848335,0.008193161626089294,0.9426554363675836,0.008691576274848335,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.029234280542198857, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern52"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.02880449760360275, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 1.2730719410820075e-06, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 46.538629890761214}",31.5,"2.22**2 * Matern(length_scale=4.73, nu=2.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)"
exymax_tw3,FlexibleMLP,0.00911171191536458,0.009211404905070629,1.0109411920210012,0.00911171191536458,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.000877490586787064, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 2, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 424}",446.42,
exymax_tw3,RandomForest,0.01113430944681164,0.008482267545648218,0.7618135265745783,0.01113430944681164,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 800}",48.35,
exymax_tw3,XGBoost,0.011415642683152592,0.009608349434540486,0.8416827419380126,0.011415642683152592,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.2, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 820, ""subsample"": 0.95}",28.14,
tfmmax_frame,SVR,1.6198986811268496,1.828107445033068,1.128531967049558,1.6198986811268496,,"{""svr__C"": 5251.84626050135, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.08533119498626765}",25.46,
tfmmax_frame,GaussianProcess,2.056564547611059,2.485330065714055,1.208486292638399,2.056564547611059,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 100.0, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.03384074056666871, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 9, ""gpr__noise"": 2.3144960576914584e-06, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.727538518541154}",35.06,"1.24**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=1e+03, length_scale=2.44) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.05e-09)"
tfmmax_frame,FlexibleMLP,5.683751754520663,5.700181636290896,1.0028906754692735,5.683751754520663,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 2.958717465055452e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.009963477697300712, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 248}",1309.93,
tfmmax_frame,GradientBoosting,7.936544787196126,5.972434040252543,0.7525231949661213,7.936544787196126,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07999999999999999, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 243, ""subsample"": 0.7}",36.78,
tfmmax_frame,XGBoost,10.948153379911536,13.204151180662365,1.206061946929817,10.948153379911536,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.2, ""max_depth"": 3, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1200, ""subsample"": 0.95}",31.19,
tfmmax_frame,RandomForest,11.264480240802971,7.007585857788552,0.6220958009589466,11.264480240802971,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",49.36,
tfmmax_tw1,GaussianProcess,11.907885871930329,15.551691134983011,1.3059993438165194,11.907885871930329,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 8.654570330937167, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.7533673127714771, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 4.4798037400923e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 6.622711593650391}",35.68,"2.42**2 * Matern(length_scale=5.66, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.98e-09)"
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,12.17385715686376,14.081170626993753,1.1566728971396407,12.17385715686376,,"{""svr__C"": 5205.98044563216, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.05264632125017639}",21.11,
tfmmax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,12.354961864931102,15.504946263241866,1.254957031251697,12.354961864931102,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.0004707265917238212, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.00040393102411379793, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 184}",734.71,
tfmmax_tw1,GradientBoosting,13.806724532232309,14.925255908256117,1.081013521593232,13.806724532232309,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07728535894770015, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 939, ""subsample"": 0.7}",41.14,
tfmmax_tw1,RandomForest,24.89042686786457,20.38569354865499,0.8190174341676104,24.89042686786457,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 0.7745354191173535, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",61.11,
tfmmax_tw1,XGBoost,25.95533524903129,29.56036364760756,1.1388935401522435,25.95533524903129,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7, ""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 702, ""subsample"": 0.7}",29.93,
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,5.241528459075318,5.774788019902097,1.1017374159065147,5.241528459075318,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.045136451590377935}",21.81,
tfmmax_tw2,GaussianProcess,6.090738224817012,5.393611825356781,0.8855432012133184,6.090738224817012,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 17.76576664980768, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RBF"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 2.467108843522573, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 8, ""gpr__noise"": 1.5290392171324112e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.024089076834871728}",29.39,2.31**2 * RBF(length_scale=2.95) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=1.53e-08)
tfmmax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,7.026650529965898,5.3818658117921645,0.7659219408793174,7.026650529965898,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.01, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 335}",750.42,
tfmmax_tw2,XGBoost,11.943326936250575,11.912424944662725,0.9974126144454728,11.943326936250575,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.2, ""max_depth"": 1, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1200, ""subsample"": 0.95}",27.49,
tfmmax_tw2,GradientBoosting,12.1756257099223,11.101262980042891,0.9117611894882842,12.1756257099223,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.06973078696326637, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 0.7361181023276857, ""n_estimators"": 449, ""subsample"": 0.7}",39.53,
tfmmax_tw2,RandomForest,16.68000477376286,17.037253718917817,1.0214177963376185,16.68000477376286,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",47.73,
tfmmax_tw3,SVR,5.366395459026223,5.457789561277232,1.0170308176035154,5.366395459026223,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.025160457729386184}",32.14,
tfmmax_tw3,GradientBoosting,7.65334044347358,13.266100360454189,1.733373872289572,7.65334044347358,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.016434122459423398, ""max_depth"": 1, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 721, ""subsample"": 0.9}",43.26,
tfmmax_tw3,GaussianProcess,8.605220627336848,10.38637558385241,1.2069853910377653,8.605220627336848,,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 15.783879853890564, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 1.2778531518898433, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 1.7014397704982245e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 7.38115974661544}",36.06,"3.25**2 * Matern(length_scale=10.7, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=4.93e-11)"
tfmmax_tw3,FlexibleMLP,9.618906649571457,9.92569415300114,1.0318942177740493,9.618906649571457,,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 1e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0001, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 512}",2138.7,
tfmmax_tw3,RandomForest,16.215182989565868,16.9215107068276,1.0435596513290193,16.215182989565868,,"{""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 200}",47.44,
tfmmax_tw3,XGBoost,23.305043207146145,24.080487409571518,1.0332736650832552,23.305043207146145,,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.7486389158913531, ""learning_rate"": 0.01, ""max_depth"": 1, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 822, ""subsample"": 0.95}",36.22,
output,best_model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,model_path,train_time_sec,gpr_kernel,selected_by
exymax_tw3,SVR,0.006722135111899321,0.003892543347026375,0.5790635389246955,0.006722135111899321,,"{""svr__C"": 9213.884743379953, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00010269561801572416, ""svr__gamma"": 0.0008423186569242777}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H45/it1/best_model_exymax_tw3.joblib,611.16,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw1,GradientBoosting,0.006809025144747611,0.009611717846807024,1.4116143856835912,0.006809025144747611,,"{""learning_rate"": 0.07917979609766448, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 0.8923682916293771, ""n_estimators"": 1467, ""subsample"": 0.7010466119809067}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H45/it1/best_model_exymax_tw1.joblib,556.91,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.00930805333,0.01190469458692915,1.2789671658369355,0.00930805333,,"{""svr__C"": 1776.5766649807683, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00032780432870046914, ""svr__gamma"": 0.006225026900894044}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H45/it1/best_model_exymax_tw2.joblib,576.32,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_frame,SVR,1.6198986811268496,1.828107445033068,1.128531967049558,1.6198986811268496,,"{""svr__C"": 5251.84626050135, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.08533119498626765}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_frame.joblib,1487.79,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,5.241528459075318,5.774788019902097,1.1017374159065147,5.241528459075318,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.045136451590377935}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw2.joblib,916.38,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw3,SVR,5.366395459026223,5.457789561277232,1.0170308176035154,5.366395459026223,,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0001, ""svr__gamma"": 0.025160457729386184}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw3.joblib,2333.82,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,12.17385715686376,14.081170626993753,1.1566728971396407,12.17385715686376,,"{""svr__C"": 5205.98044563216, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.05264632125017639}",../../models/width_optimization/3W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H45/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw1.joblib,923.68,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
output,LOO_RMSE,LOO_MAE,LOO_R2,LOO_RMSE_STD,LOO_RMSE_CV,LOO_MAE_STD,LOO_SQERR_STD
exymax_tw1,0.009664738844235058,0.006891541645517656,0.8282511575440406,0.006775974518500035,0.9832305842492025,0.006775974518500035,0.0001866858647809949
exymax_tw2,0.008794896944852741,0.006893913242805494,0.9115500846632101,0.005461151203844399,0.7921699927894611,0.005461151203844399,9.89250222213258e-05
exymax_tw3,0.011642649362181996,0.00786764859416453,0.9415784387712007,0.00858203878862463,1.0908009789595796,0.00858203878862463,0.00025164733549623553
tfmmax_tw1,16.674188569297787,10.569415176666508,0.8826408295131737,12.89635713167686,1.2201580613606142,12.89635713167686,526.2958511297622
tfmmax_tw2,9.876659773351388,7.197513519697939,0.9558823259222151,6.7634464152754905,0.9396920751542173,6.7634464152754905,174.50737634617838
tfmmax_tw3,14.766156027746682,9.464551738380948,0.9606403016800643,11.334091239586431,1.1975306969503974,11.334091239586431,404.66393630766
tfmmax_frame,6.972755565036954,5.268329306236887,0.9580580629748319,4.567715675345761,0.8670140778668282,4.567715675345761,97.81529326270824
output,LOO_RMSE,LOO_MAE,LOO_R2,LOO_RMSE_STD,LOO_RMSE_CV,LOO_MAE_STD,LOO_SQERR_STD
exymax_tw1,0.011989772947555107,0.007804076484253263,0.821463371495126,0.009102254971261218,1.1663462024785847,0.009102254971261218,0.0003177020710335127
exymax_tw2,0.016094319221679768,0.01010286649554208,0.7231557726541351,0.012528335874432169,1.2400773463610881,0.012528335874432169,0.0006070504083770877
exymax_tw3,0.012443998275974838,0.0085123952161833,0.9449281900502644,0.009077016072254385,1.0663292577155792,0.009077016072254385,0.00026811474326490087
tfmmax_tw1,21.010582238539605,12.366664872259886,0.8829571560704604,16.985587006036887,1.3734978008612388,16.985587006036887,842.375323080444
tfmmax_tw2,11.24664836103733,7.516935886297351,0.9561166531555773,8.36557076583055,1.1128963838949562,8.36557076583055,234.798887397094
tfmmax_tw3,16.792237270490816,10.456662531718287,0.9506228597144651,13.139156793577728,1.256534458649938,13.139156793577728,562.8764003179608
tfmmax_frame,7.090027087624625,4.7494105218496365,0.9474015015279276,5.264179309084644,1.108385827013019,5.264179309084644,124.26727514349405
output,model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,fit_time_sec,gpr_kernel
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.006503353982891545,0.0016733166016384376,0.25730055691885334,0.004795850696074186,0.9480929776752609,"{""svr__C"": 6823.003596004928, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.000844079154363363, ""svr__gamma"": 0.0004915228293583758}",21.55,
exymax_tw1,GaussianProcess,0.007313687465951828,0.0020743503678201467,0.28362578760400775,0.005291900740335189,0.9301499423757796,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.010340016434251914, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 9.228497044562662, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 3, ""gpr__noise"": 4.2590691354469774e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.1255623384550418}",32.26,"5.79**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=0.569, length_scale=7.77) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.01)"
exymax_tw1,XGBoost,0.008123675194495621,0.003440640275912072,0.42353247680844686,0.00530347094204934,0.9169341458481892,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.01699059180718313, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 1, ""n_estimators"": 1600, ""subsample"": 0.6}",32.59,
exymax_tw1,GradientBoosting,0.008329391327427743,0.0032486678942851787,0.3900246448486197,0.005416784537354479,0.9137387133085667,"{""learning_rate"": 0.054975090685582734, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 300, ""subsample"": 0.6260163570329387}",63.71,
exymax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,0.00869242926653178,0.0025201091805081284,0.2899200100725852,0.006158556323690138,0.8951900280655403,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.0015246748254295628, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.007340675018434775, ""mlp__n_layers"": 2, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 364}",643.18,
exymax_tw1,RandomForest,0.011145770392690635,0.00336801869076167,0.3021790842713221,0.007491001794056498,0.8505958117127195,"{""max_depth"": 8, ""max_features"": 0.9696848688013859, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 1020}",62.79,
exymax_tw2,GaussianProcess,0.005175288000313258,0.001355713983974814,0.2619591380987403,0.003930023298248029,0.9634272451007215,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.9038591357349409, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern52"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 3.6501557994627607, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 5, ""gpr__noise"": 3.2412265507088655e-12, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.014281382695758474}",34.03,"3.29**2 * Matern(length_scale=7.02, nu=2.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=3.24e-12)"
exymax_tw2,SVR,0.005883606304671026,0.0013344806391647776,0.22681338112397603,0.004543351140587523,0.9525767047189229,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0011991360850500364, ""svr__gamma"": 0.0017300936198162379}",19.1,
exymax_tw2,GradientBoosting,0.006355616010011005,0.0017631515946733157,0.27741631840188263,0.004376078177608559,0.9428379168452035,"{""learning_rate"": 0.006034004103310313, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2500, ""subsample"": 0.6}",51.03,
exymax_tw2,XGBoost,0.0065746907401931995,0.0012791155019899999,0.1945514325366447,0.004766918974491237,0.9401959318000108,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.014503204521732394, ""max_depth"": 4, ""min_child_weight"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 734, ""subsample"": 0.6755459197531244}",28.07,
exymax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,0.007109631985182298,0.0024477620957169995,0.34428815736434165,0.0050954465928471785,0.9323122139639771,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.004774443242743466, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.005015906643367064, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 381}",1061.52,
exymax_tw2,RandomForest,0.007137003985460298,0.0017073642143572354,0.2392270226884453,0.0050014959723538146,0.9263777727895179,"{""max_depth"": 10, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 300}",64.7,
exymax_tw3,XGBoost,0.011013573528721066,0.00344371544014144,0.31267920726737425,0.007661595346904032,0.8870903297149664,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.012332964227841255, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 1, ""n_estimators"": 1600, ""subsample"": 0.6}",33.4,
exymax_tw3,GradientBoosting,0.011272462091644599,0.0038538792537674755,0.3418844279480041,0.007796680537328976,0.8889872654721852,"{""learning_rate"": 0.006017744203993281, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2500, ""subsample"": 0.6}",56.78,
exymax_tw3,SVR,0.012923403960431465,0.004307928102080536,0.333343143592078,0.008939866466547099,0.8602282858833765,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00023702399897867961, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00016330753646600886}",18.74,
exymax_tw3,RandomForest,0.013119457980136834,0.003922240907931768,0.2989636396465565,0.00930122113956057,0.8501926946068096,"{""max_depth"": 10, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""min_samples_leaf"": 1, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 300}",62.55,
exymax_tw3,GaussianProcess,0.013402171213075909,0.0037991420987431536,0.28347213584590664,0.009617026956924731,0.8448525031067646,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.01, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.01, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 0.0001, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.01}",36.68,"4.33**2 * Matern(length_scale=10.6, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)"
exymax_tw3,FlexibleMLP,0.013491573257966622,0.005053338887811329,0.37455519761769734,0.009207460188627822,0.8376409082858582,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.01, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0010175471586308853, ""mlp__n_layers"": 4, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 512}",1260.81,
exymax_tw4,GaussianProcess,0.006769305695857214,0.0020325653227172714,0.3002620082531053,0.004797231634312929,0.9477528187559967,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.01, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.13251748163101026, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 1, ""gpr__noise"": 4.323002328767807e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 76.11531739071764}",30.9,"4.3**2 * Matern(length_scale=13.5, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=4.4e-08)"
exymax_tw4,SVR,0.007487237065078578,0.0019188382544815207,0.256281220669668,0.005444526899668071,0.934389186578286,"{""svr__C"": 9816.21006050226, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0007026205523921609, ""svr__gamma"": 0.0011123179560004017}",21.25,
exymax_tw4,FlexibleMLP,0.008404286650936309,0.0029109009754088016,0.34635907796939586,0.006123279212398965,0.9183888562759067,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.0018606110480877869, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.004761260941337373, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 64}",922.75,
exymax_tw4,GradientBoosting,0.009978220139843558,0.0033307895059017066,0.3338059753363918,0.007640010207606629,0.8883773086274374,"{""learning_rate"": 0.021793511470937988, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 1197, ""subsample"": 0.6}",53.67,
exymax_tw4,XGBoost,0.010291652891168866,0.0030681860400674082,0.2981237389671565,0.007857573703293822,0.8815524924923308,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.007545324726624907, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 1, ""n_estimators"": 1600, ""subsample"": 0.6}",36.24,
exymax_tw4,RandomForest,0.01296832176573334,0.0039837322484333965,0.3071894976387581,0.009914125053372035,0.8153071891421444,"{""max_depth"": 10, ""max_features"": 0.8080429668210642, ""min_samples_leaf"": 1, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 513}",68.75,
exymax_tw5,GaussianProcess,0.0038085629773573397,0.0013816561051710407,0.36277622646264734,0.002657754913972533,0.9448032776668865,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.39676834201369987, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern52"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 11.801983715610099, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 4.062992821534264e-11, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 1.0729935500711}",30.32,"2.84**2 * Matern(length_scale=6.11, nu=2.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)"
exymax_tw5,SVR,0.004090030637256585,0.001540605533326916,0.3766733479434979,0.002944314597970106,0.9353030498262586,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.00019619549175362865, ""svr__gamma"": 0.04679088824552713}",17.86,
exymax_tw5,FlexibleMLP,0.0054155327526707745,0.0018695762343000869,0.34522480422227514,0.0040348059658096725,0.8890993900057728,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 1.3635182383483688e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.006439728369485328, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 241}",1263.25,
exymax_tw5,GradientBoosting,0.006130514770950657,0.00132252052749501,0.21572748405431655,0.004547147547623821,0.8612302236034786,"{""learning_rate"": 0.04327948592119732, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 924, ""subsample"": 0.6}",54.04,
exymax_tw5,XGBoost,0.006330917777032848,0.0015769718625351706,0.24909056128576987,0.0047138903105750285,0.8494830850450501,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.03161340454735771, ""max_depth"": 6, ""min_child_weight"": 9, ""n_estimators"": 1600, ""subsample"": 1.0}",29.9,
exymax_tw5,RandomForest,0.007564471943052495,0.0017230347430242637,0.22777991061316127,0.005716063978257455,0.7918213052620856,"{""max_depth"": 10, ""max_features"": 0.8546522860334106, ""min_samples_leaf"": 1, ""min_samples_split"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 992}",67.12,
tfmmax_frame,SVR,7.173951665738949,1.8431934056692432,0.2569286066522984,5.441946933013678,0.6524629625231141,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0007486677715870227, ""svr__gamma"": 0.004158300075238015}",25.79,
tfmmax_frame,GradientBoosting,8.027394508437487,2.0777139643307807,0.25882793752654404,5.819151838372137,0.5685588183473789,"{""learning_rate"": 0.013354900265324765, ""max_depth"": 4, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2020, ""subsample"": 0.6}",54.98,
tfmmax_frame,GaussianProcess,8.208406654677097,2.4126353399194898,0.29392249207643556,6.049532940907539,0.5495930712620065,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 100.0, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 4.571223534062345, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 8, ""gpr__noise"": 0.0001, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 100.0}",31.03,"1.56**2 * Matern(length_scale=2.94, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.0001)"
tfmmax_frame,XGBoost,8.434021736431662,1.784667210848021,0.21160334495451436,6.226041585466722,0.5162363067793966,"{""colsample_bytree"": 0.6, ""learning_rate"": 0.06562638337224148, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 1, ""n_estimators"": 300, ""subsample"": 0.6579813161992569}",32.65,
tfmmax_frame,RandomForest,8.889401055745338,2.5105776654506773,0.28242371445577397,6.5109087769696785,0.48547849578906144,"{""max_depth"": 9, ""max_features"": 0.6725752970106076, ""min_samples_leaf"": 1, ""min_samples_split"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 984}",73.23,
tfmmax_frame,FlexibleMLP,10.284830316474334,2.6800046776611453,0.2605784048151275,8.247456858758161,0.12899459710464395,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.00030206883147584093, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 151}",1183.44,
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,9.525684223293123,3.4996709899329,0.36739313501230353,6.56127396437163,0.9588915907496363,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.009046278617242663}",26.79,
tfmmax_tw1,GradientBoosting,10.543729207730365,4.549705080980932,0.4315081496635191,7.184348677984953,0.9448827777983011,"{""learning_rate"": 0.008967775885328665, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2500, ""subsample"": 0.6}",66.54,
tfmmax_tw1,FlexibleMLP,10.785703301266807,3.0952682528224886,0.28697880577328155,7.801407299950299,0.9423667020698563,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.00158783346525754, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.003424697639000501, ""mlp__n_layers"": 3, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 363}",891.13,
tfmmax_tw1,XGBoost,11.173428897720685,3.762894828918249,0.33677171648587284,7.84801060212749,0.9386964393642927,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.08773846951378263, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 2, ""n_estimators"": 1098, ""subsample"": 0.7489920188979773}",33.88,
tfmmax_tw1,GaussianProcess,11.455704987380152,3.63636156708138,0.31742800387119546,8.229895661643557,0.9338873610523187,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.02344673599992639, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 15.279414848159554, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 6, ""gpr__noise"": 3.2972412089155123e-07, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.4280403260490878}",37.38,"6.47**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=0.71, length_scale=7.98) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.01)"
tfmmax_tw1,RandomForest,14.550646649847186,4.917573116313791,0.337962513601788,9.92063707991279,0.904440581607998,"{""max_depth"": 9, ""max_features"": 0.9654940586565877, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 1200}",94.42,
tfmmax_tw2,SVR,7.094943468431064,1.5502587082509853,0.21850191127651095,5.554405650128439,0.9769196799428093,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.017353358839239923}",28.05,
tfmmax_tw2,GaussianProcess,7.300452128021403,1.1889497278125405,0.16285973895356182,5.866149725588835,0.9759116086021171,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 2.9397976202716882, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.2729554233267, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 9, ""gpr__noise"": 5.507536733594563e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 2.3904526209366392}",35.92,"5.28**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=0.685, length_scale=7.69) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.00383)"
tfmmax_tw2,FlexibleMLP,8.980313236048298,2.4812771686426163,0.2763018508844886,6.92597986537272,0.9601558357664723,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.0009912233917797714, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0012135347998640553, ""mlp__n_layers"": 4, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 328}",1372.21,
tfmmax_tw2,XGBoost,9.463315100748412,1.6593181194309832,0.17534216094101684,7.288228228349124,0.959794993713501,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.0536658882339305, ""max_depth"": 6, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 300, ""subsample"": 0.6}",32.1,
tfmmax_tw2,GradientBoosting,9.707107197233587,2.6657094366541862,0.27461419581457625,7.317614360739552,0.9578534702608523,"{""learning_rate"": 0.013411673545405284, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2500, ""subsample"": 0.6}",60.71,
tfmmax_tw2,RandomForest,12.033802523681945,2.869156888314172,0.23842479404725223,9.10466545664493,0.9346230395314219,"{""max_depth"": 10, ""max_features"": 0.8622355763677165, ""min_samples_leaf"": 1, ""min_samples_split"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 834}",73.23,
tfmmax_tw3,GaussianProcess,8.959109214839248,2.8746947879788087,0.320868371960168,6.766563539659049,0.9801173013302533,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 9.320085469778533, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 4.301128859377977, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 3, ""gpr__noise"": 1.7734870980832062e-06, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.030696207465012934}",41.44,"8.27**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=1.97, length_scale=9.58) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.0044)"
tfmmax_tw3,SVR,9.084327937865812,3.399169652185433,0.3741795403506759,6.860140984936072,0.9783538295839298,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.011030611600943777}",30.62,
tfmmax_tw3,GradientBoosting,13.142187694978848,5.532991173585357,0.4210099035261315,9.481041320563794,0.9574239732726376,"{""learning_rate"": 0.010720194567002387, ""max_depth"": 3, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2500, ""subsample"": 0.6}",61.96,
tfmmax_tw3,XGBoost,14.069554583063965,4.4738149624820736,0.3179784360670072,10.540901357930128,0.950212454714622,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.04653420719585716, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 1600, ""subsample"": 0.6}",35.21,
tfmmax_tw3,FlexibleMLP,15.179639465184541,2.966331300798182,0.19541513535954855,12.024684470626529,0.9413370785994577,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 1e-05, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.01, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 212}",1322.58,
tfmmax_tw3,RandomForest,18.29525858985319,6.690885827934416,0.36571693125153615,13.490408379480252,0.9169156385292666,"{""max_depth"": 6, ""max_features"": 0.9687325139343489, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 985}",81.06,
tfmmax_tw4,GaussianProcess,5.231381670900287,1.9379521427685364,0.3704474772981011,3.9069887164089083,0.9782857639915543,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 9.857730593861822, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.643957343373082, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 7, ""gpr__noise"": 8.341820189392369e-05, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 50.981102496420675}",36.27,"7**2 * Matern(length_scale=23.5, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=8.37e-11)"
tfmmax_tw4,SVR,5.241649895130784,1.5671405810817105,0.29897849197015264,3.838703061276039,0.9785940660157522,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00974221935923807}",23.23,
tfmmax_tw4,FlexibleMLP,8.26972676775285,2.1561541210539334,0.2607285804727778,6.306213518165311,0.9469445266117281,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.004680330985281854, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.009096443295125272, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 203}",1166.01,
tfmmax_tw4,GradientBoosting,8.68616033236549,2.4770674367486167,0.28517404030856064,6.685058299591615,0.9413352197461687,"{""learning_rate"": 0.019812880300430248, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2500, ""subsample"": 0.6}",66.24,
tfmmax_tw4,XGBoost,9.33288276142842,2.6250085148891533,0.28126449051068864,7.256553714305651,0.9322365004973356,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.09779096738681156, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 3, ""n_estimators"": 300, ""subsample"": 0.6}",34.95,
tfmmax_tw4,RandomForest,12.402147199472287,2.738086894811146,0.2207752295447398,9.669503192616242,0.8848215323571729,"{""max_depth"": 7, ""max_features"": 0.9607723688386156, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 417}",76.42,
tfmmax_tw5,SVR,4.0603202034361265,0.8593661035065214,0.2116498355916033,3.1070328661360285,0.9668865849438951,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.02481746750486418}",27.67,
tfmmax_tw5,GaussianProcess,4.141400070328251,1.3266274854074294,0.3203330909544993,3.0135295573268808,0.9663534853665515,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 100.0, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 100.0, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 1e-12, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 100.0}",32.81,"6.13**2 * Matern(length_scale=20.9, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)"
tfmmax_tw5,FlexibleMLP,6.813958930950993,1.2709503894092053,0.18652158052144652,5.371788272329492,0.9111339894686926,"{""mlp__activation"": ""relu"", ""mlp__alpha"": 0.01, ""mlp__learning_rate_init"": 0.0037273500540683496, ""mlp__n_layers"": 5, ""mlp__n_neurons"": 509}",1467.45,
tfmmax_tw5,GradientBoosting,8.149551029043888,1.6691385401290701,0.20481355772612359,6.170320622447076,0.8755069123188104,"{""learning_rate"": 0.010813596538599014, ""max_depth"": 2, ""max_features"": 1.0, ""n_estimators"": 2500, ""subsample"": 0.6}",67.53,
tfmmax_tw5,XGBoost,8.583056348923272,1.4900724478136544,0.17360627581113122,6.551516245931737,0.8603680426499082,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.017892496888149464, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 5, ""n_estimators"": 1350, ""subsample"": 0.6}",33.71,
tfmmax_tw5,RandomForest,10.921201396226943,2.5573903902367916,0.23416749654670035,8.709629793907204,0.7811996866882791,"{""max_depth"": 8, ""max_features"": 0.9668859477087186, ""min_samples_leaf"": 2, ""min_samples_split"": 4, ""n_estimators"": 1188}",83.09,
output,best_model,cv_rmse,std_rmse,cv_rmse_dispersion,cv_mae,cv_r2,BEST_PARAMS,model_path,train_time_sec,gpr_kernel,selected_by
exymax_tw5,GaussianProcess,0.0038085629773573397,0.0013816561051710407,0.36277622646264734,0.002657754913972533,0.9448032776668865,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.39676834201369987, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern52"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 11.801983715610099, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 10, ""gpr__noise"": 4.062992821534264e-11, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 1.0729935500711}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_exymax_tw5.joblib,1462.49,"2.84**2 * Matern(length_scale=6.11, nu=2.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=2.91e-12)",lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw2,GaussianProcess,0.005175288000313258,0.001355713983974814,0.2619591380987403,0.003930023298248029,0.9634272451007215,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.9038591357349409, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern52"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 3.6501557994627607, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 5, ""gpr__noise"": 3.2412265507088655e-12, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.014281382695758474}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_exymax_tw2.joblib,1258.45,"3.29**2 * Matern(length_scale=7.02, nu=2.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=3.24e-12)",lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw1,SVR,0.006503353982891545,0.0016733166016384376,0.25730055691885334,0.004795850696074186,0.9480929776752609,"{""svr__C"": 6823.003596004928, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.000844079154363363, ""svr__gamma"": 0.0004915228293583758}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_exymax_tw1.joblib,856.1,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw4,GaussianProcess,0.006769305695857214,0.0020325653227172714,0.3002620082531053,0.004797231634312929,0.9477528187559967,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 0.01, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""Matern32"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.13251748163101026, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 1, ""gpr__noise"": 4.323002328767807e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 76.11531739071764}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_exymax_tw4.joblib,1133.58,"4.3**2 * Matern(length_scale=13.5, nu=1.5) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=4.4e-08)",lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
exymax_tw3,XGBoost,0.011013573528721066,0.00344371544014144,0.31267920726737425,0.007661595346904032,0.8870903297149664,"{""colsample_bytree"": 1.0, ""learning_rate"": 0.012332964227841255, ""max_depth"": 2, ""min_child_weight"": 1, ""n_estimators"": 1600, ""subsample"": 0.6}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_exymax_tw3.joblib,1469.03,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw5,SVR,4.0603202034361265,0.8593661035065214,0.2116498355916033,3.1070328661360285,0.9668865849438951,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.02481746750486418}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw5.joblib,1712.26,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw4,SVR,5.241649895130784,1.5671405810817105,0.29897849197015264,3.838703061276039,0.9785940660157522,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.00974221935923807}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw4.joblib,1403.13,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_frame,SVR,7.173951665738949,1.8431934056692432,0.2569286066522984,5.441946933013678,0.6524629625231141,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.0007486677715870227, ""svr__gamma"": 0.004158300075238015}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_tfmmax_frame.joblib,1401.13,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw2,GaussianProcess,7.300452128021403,1.1889497278125405,0.16285973895356182,5.866149725588835,0.9759116086021171,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 2.9397976202716882, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 0.2729554233267, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 9, ""gpr__noise"": 5.507536733594563e-08, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 2.3904526209366392}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw2.joblib,1602.23,"5.28**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=0.685, length_scale=7.69) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.00383)",lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw3,GaussianProcess,8.959109214839248,2.8746947879788087,0.320868371960168,6.766563539659049,0.9801173013302533,"{""gpr__amplitude"": 9.320085469778533, ""gpr__kernel_type"": ""RQ"", ""gpr__length_scale"": 4.301128859377977, ""gpr__n_restarts_optimizer"": 3, ""gpr__noise"": 1.7734870980832062e-06, ""gpr__rq_alpha"": 0.030696207465012934}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw3.joblib,1572.88,"8.27**2 * RationalQuadratic(alpha=1.97, length_scale=9.58) + WhiteKernel(noise_level=0.0044)",lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
tfmmax_tw1,SVR,9.525684223293123,3.4996709899329,0.36739313501230353,6.56127396437163,0.9588915907496363,"{""svr__C"": 10000.0, ""svr__epsilon"": 0.1, ""svr__gamma"": 0.009046278617242663}",../../models/width_optimization/5W/ml_models/per_output_models_B34_H60/it1/best_model_tfmmax_tw1.joblib,1150.14,,lowest_cv_rmse_dispersion_within_5pct_rmse_band
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,2.0
Configuration_B,29.0
Configuration_H,30.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,1.0
tw1_optimal,12.533740683512349
tw2_optimal,14.746138146053648
Objective_score,-1.5542226609604432e-06
Exy_tw1,0.04601916356910496
Exy_tw2,0.060608620602577025
TFM_tw1,90.00000004321747
TFM_tw2,90.00000002552895
TFM_frame,89.3236419362625
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,2.0
Configuration_B,34.0
Configuration_H,30.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,1.0
tw1_optimal,15.142233883972198
tw2_optimal,20.0
Objective_score,830.1911577081513
Exy_tw1,0.05444326530066618
Exy_tw2,0.044415233081057104
TFM_tw1,110.55081870186555
TFM_tw2,71.35298892365586
TFM_frame,97.30119452174736
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,2.0
Configuration_B,29.0
Configuration_H,30.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,2.0
tw1_optimal,12.564217655339927
tw2_optimal,14.791200827941779
Objective_score,-1.5407893799600598e-06
Exy_tw1,0.045533045964018304
Exy_tw2,0.060421190391879626
TFM_tw1,90.0000000202229
TFM_tw2,90.00000003562494
TFM_frame,86.88234160587658
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,2.0
Configuration_B,34.0
Configuration_H,30.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,2.0
tw1_optimal,14.772996904210258
tw2_optimal,18.947870155375433
Objective_score,688.5304119448903
Exy_tw1,0.053945249001367324
Exy_tw2,0.04908314547155923
TFM_tw1,109.60872551274139
TFM_tw2,78.48716961267957
TFM_frame,96.63818897746123
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,3.0
Configuration_B,29.0
Configuration_H,45.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,1.0
tw1_optimal,5.69517840236932
tw2_optimal,7.903893902027944
tw3_optimal,9.021901695737641
Objective_score,-1.085533524925096e-06
Exy_tw1,0.04800757315309729
Exy_tw2,0.04780064950486884
Exy_tw3,0.04930233962298178
TFM_tw1,90.00000000583222
TFM_tw2,90.00000001121359
TFM_tw3,90.00000003640244
TFM_frame,71.22253736548598
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,3.0
Configuration_B,34.0
Configuration_H,45.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,1.0
tw1_optimal,6.874863063649432
tw2_optimal,9.078328256110343
tw3_optimal,9.855301373461515
Objective_score,-1.5128003660636569e-06
Exy_tw1,0.036116216315330976
Exy_tw2,0.050128444520544324
Exy_tw3,0.05362486510382558
TFM_tw1,90.00000000043133
TFM_tw2,90.00000001623542
TFM_tw3,90.00000001397498
TFM_frame,68.41841407058793
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,3.0
Configuration_B,29.0
Configuration_H,45.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,2.0
tw1_optimal,5.8108938768347596
tw2_optimal,7.879428503335146
tw3_optimal,8.98351290305241
Objective_score,-1.1761537616766776e-06
Exy_tw1,0.047224209593164757
Exy_tw2,0.04866570926418015
Exy_tw3,0.054160280376656655
TFM_tw1,90.00000000249167
TFM_tw2,90.00000000096668
TFM_tw3,90.00000000064563
TFM_frame,69.16959381047411
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,3.0
Configuration_B,34.0
Configuration_H,45.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,2.0
tw1_optimal,6.824813707164065
tw2_optimal,8.975723721326078
tw3_optimal,9.673693648288205
Objective_score,-1.5036470193089083e-06
Exy_tw1,0.04207613237690064
Exy_tw2,0.04671777307468361
Exy_tw3,0.05387304603413823
TFM_tw1,90.00000004002021
TFM_tw2,90.00000003705242
TFM_tw3,90.00000005796741
TFM_frame,69.04446249717469
Parameter,Value
Configuration_W,5.0
Configuration_B,34.0
Configuration_H,60.0
Configuration_TFD_W,90.0
Iteration,1.0
tw1_optimal,5.759921476551572
tw2_optimal,7.3711507027129075
tw3_optimal,8.456689063290359
tw4_optimal,6.668376537250182
tw5_optimal,5.0
Objective_score,16.960815946902244
Exy_tw1,0.06149628053180933
Exy_tw2,0.053127626566851494
Exy_tw3,0.06014397740364075
Exy_tw4,0.07067358204821853
Exy_tw5,0.05734081700027541
TFM_tw1,90.00000302054411
TFM_tw2,90.00000046377134
TFM_tw3,90.00000018993417
TFM_tw4,90.00001156625868
TFM_tw5,73.03918138711484
TFM_frame,74.84972818192045
#!/bin/bash #!/bin/bash
python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 29 --it 0 python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 29 --it 1
python ml_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 0 python ml_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 1
python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 34 --it 0 python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 34 --it 1
python ml_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 0 python ml_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 1
python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 29 --it 0 python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 29 --it 1
python ml_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 0 python ml_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 1
python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 34 --it 0 python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 34 --it 1
python ml_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 0 python ml_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 1
python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 5 --B 34 --it 0 python ml_surrogate_train.py --W 5 --B 34 --it 1
python ml_optimization_de.py --W 5 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 0 python ml_optimization_de.py --W 5 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 1
#!/bin/bash #!/bin/bash
python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 29 --it 1 python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 29 --it 2
python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 1 python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 2
python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 34 --it 1 python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 2 --B 34 --it 2
python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 1 python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 2 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 2
python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 29 --it 1 python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 29 --it 2
python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 1 python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 29 --TFD_W 90 --it 2
python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 34 --it 1 python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 3 --B 34 --it 2
python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 1 python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 3 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 2
##python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 5 --B 34 --it 2 ##python rbf_surrogate_train.py --W 5 --B 34 --it 2
##python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 5 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 2 ##python rbf_optimization_de.py --W 5 --B 34 --TFD_W 90 --it 2
Manuscript/Figures/Device.png

233 KB | W: | H:

Manuscript/Figures/Device.png

155 KB | W: | H:

Manuscript/Figures/Device.png
Manuscript/Figures/Device.png
Manuscript/Figures/Device.png
Manuscript/Figures/Device.png
  • 2-up
  • Swipe
  • Onion skin
This source diff could not be displayed because it is too large. You can view the blob instead.
This source diff could not be displayed because it is too large. You can view the blob instead.
...@@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ ...@@ -25,7 +25,7 @@
\begin{document} \begin{document}
\title{Adaptive FEM-validated surrogate optimization of buckling-delayed shear-link dampers for seismic damage mitigation} \title{Damage-aware surrogate optimization of buckling-delayed shear-link dampers with adaptive finite element validation}
\author[1]{J. Irazábal} \author[1]{J. Irazábal}
\author[1,2]{J. Ramírez} \author[1,2]{J. Ramírez}
...@@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ ...@@ -36,7 +36,7 @@
\author[4]{L. Bozzo} \author[4]{L. Bozzo}
\authormark{IRAZÁBAL \textsc{et al.}} \authormark{IRAZÁBAL \textsc{et al.}}
\titlemark{ADAPTIVE FEM-VALIDATED SURROGATE OPTIMIZATION OF BDSL DAMPERS} \titlemark{DAMAGE-AWARE SURROGATE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR-LINK DAMPERS}
\address[1]{\orgname{Centre Internacional de Metodes Numerics en Enginyeria (CIMNE)}, \orgaddress{\city{Barcelona}, \country{Spain}}} \address[1]{\orgname{Centre Internacional de Metodes Numerics en Enginyeria (CIMNE)}, \orgaddress{\city{Barcelona}, \country{Spain}}}
\address[2]{\orgname{Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya (UPC)}, \orgaddress{\city{Barcelona}, \country{Spain}}} \address[2]{\orgname{Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya (UPC)}, \orgaddress{\city{Barcelona}, \country{Spain}}}
...@@ -45,9 +45,9 @@ ...@@ -45,9 +45,9 @@
\corres{J. Irazábal. \email{jirazabal@cimne.upc.edu}} \corres{J. Irazábal. \email{jirazabal@cimne.upc.edu}}
\abstract[Abstract]{Buckling-delayed shear-link (BDSL) dampers are used in seismic-resistant structures as passive devices that concentrate energy dissipation while limiting damage to the primary system. Their geometric optimization requires a compromise between high energy dissipation and control of local damage. Finite element method (FEM) models can reproduce with high accuracy the nonlinear cyclic response of these devices and provide damage indicators and local distortion, but their computational cost prevents their direct use inside iterative optimization loops. This work proposes an adaptive surrogate-assisted optimization framework for BDSL dampers. First, experimentally calibrated nonlinear FEM models are used to generate ground-truth datasets for dampers with different geometric and mechanical configurations. Supervised learning models are first evaluated, where Support Vector Regression (SVR) and Gaussian Process Regression (GPR)—both based on radial kernel functions—consistently provide the highest predictive accuracy. Motivated by this observation, Radial Basis Function (RBF) surrogates are subsequently introduced as a computationally efficient alternative. The surrogate predictions are coupled with a Differential Evolution algorithm through a damage-aware objective function that limits the damage and uses dissipated energy as a tie-breaking performance criterion. In addition, SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) are employed to quantify the influence of window thickness on damage distribution, with particular emphasis on the response of the surrounding frame. Optimized geometries are finally re-evaluated with FEM. When the surrogate error exceeds the adopted tolerances, the new FEM result is added to the dataset and the surrogate models are retrained. The proposed framework provides a scalable route for an efficient damage-aware optimization of seismic energy dissipation devices.} \abstract[Abstract]{Buckling-delayed shear-link (BDSL) dampers are used in seismic-resistant structures as passive devices that concentrate energy dissipation while limiting damage to the primary system. Their geometric optimization requires a compromise between high energy dissipation and control of local damage. Finite element method (FEM) models can reproduce with high accuracy the nonlinear cyclic response of these devices and provide damage indicators and local distortion, but their computational cost prevents their direct use inside iterative optimization loops. This work proposes an adaptive surrogate-assisted optimization framework for BDSL dampers. First, experimentally calibrated nonlinear FEM models are used to generate ground-truth datasets for dampers with different geometric and mechanical configurations. Supervised learning models are first evaluated, where Support Vector Regression (SVR) and Gaussian Process Regression (GPR)—both based on radial kernel functions—consistently provide high predictive accuracy. Motivated by this observation, Radial Basis Function (RBF) surrogates are introduced as a computationally efficient alternative. The surrogate predictions are coupled with a Differential Evolution algorithm through a damage-aware objective function that limits the damage and uses dissipated energy as a tie-breaking performance criterion. Optimized geometries are finally re-evaluated with FEM. When the surrogate error exceeds the adopted tolerances, the new FEM result is added to the dataset and the surrogate models are retrained. In addition, SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) are employed to quantify the influence of window thickness on damage distribution, with particular emphasis on the response of the surrounding frame. The proposed framework provides a scalable route for an efficient damage-aware optimization of seismic energy dissipation devices.}
\keywords{Buckling-delayed shear link, seismic energy dissipation, surrogate modelling, machine learning, radial basis functions, Differential Evolution, FEM validation, TFDMap} \keywords{Buckling-delayed shear link, seismic energy dissipation, FEM validation, surrogate modelling, machine learning, radial basis functions, Differential Evolution, SHAP.}
\jnlcitation{\cname{% \jnlcitation{\cname{%
\author{Irazábal J.}, \author{Irazábal J.},
...@@ -57,7 +57,7 @@ ...@@ -57,7 +57,7 @@
\author{Rastellini F.}, \author{Rastellini F.},
\author{Bozzo G.}, and \author{Bozzo G.}, and
\author{Bozzo L.}}. \author{Bozzo L.}}.
\ctitle{Adaptive FEM-validated surrogate optimization of buckling-delayed shear-link dampers for seismic damage mitigation.} \cjournal{\it Journal.} \cvol{2026;00(00):1--18}.} \ctitle{Damage-aware surrogate optimization of buckling-delayed shear-link dampers with adaptive finite element validation.} \cjournal{\it Journal.} \cvol{2026;00(00):1--18}.}
\maketitle \maketitle
...@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ All these works demonstrate the increasing interest in applying FEM-based and da ...@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ All these works demonstrate the increasing interest in applying FEM-based and da
The present work addresses this gap through a damage-aware surrogate-assisted optimization methodology in which the objective is not only to maximize distortion or energy dissipation, but also to balance dissipative performance with damage indicators derived from FEM simulations. The proposed approach combines: (i) experimentally calibrated nonlinear FEM models used as numerical ground truth; (ii) supervised surrogate models trained to predict local damage and distortion indicators; (iii) a Differential Evolution (DE) optimizer; and (iv) an adaptive FEM validation and retraining loop. The present work addresses this gap through a damage-aware surrogate-assisted optimization methodology in which the objective is not only to maximize distortion or energy dissipation, but also to balance dissipative performance with damage indicators derived from FEM simulations. The proposed approach combines: (i) experimentally calibrated nonlinear FEM models used as numerical ground truth; (ii) supervised surrogate models trained to predict local damage and distortion indicators; (iii) a Differential Evolution (DE) optimizer; and (iv) an adaptive FEM validation and retraining loop.
Figure \ref{fig:MethodologyFlowChart} summarizes the proposed workflow. The different stages of the methodology, together with the surrogate modelling, optimization strategy, validation procedure, and corresponding results, are described in the following sections. Figure \ref{fig:MethodologyFlowChart} summarizes the proposed workflow. The different stages of the methodology, together with the surrogate modelling, optimization strategy, validation procedure and corresponding results, are described in the following sections.
\begin{figure}[!ht] \begin{figure}[!ht]
\centering \centering
...@@ -94,12 +94,12 @@ Figure \ref{fig:MethodologyFlowChart} summarizes the proposed workflow. The diff ...@@ -94,12 +94,12 @@ Figure \ref{fig:MethodologyFlowChart} summarizes the proposed workflow. The diff
\section{Buckling-delayed shear-link damper}\label{sec:device} \section{Buckling-delayed shear-link damper}\label{sec:device}
The BDSL dampers analysed in this work, with one representative configuration shown in Figure \ref{fig:Device}, are designed to concentrate energy dissipation in localized reduced-thickness zones, hereafter referred to as \ti{windows}, while preserving the structural integrity of the surrounding frame. The dissipative element is connected to a load-transfer system through a mechanism that allows imposed in-plane displacement while preventing axial force transmission, thereby promoting a shear-dominated response. Under cyclic loading, plastic deformation is intended to concentrate in the windows, whereas the frame provides load transfer and stability. The BDSL dampers analysed in this work, with one representative configuration shown in Figure \ref{fig:Device}, are designed to concentrate energy dissipation in localized reduced-thickness zones, hereafter referred to as windows, while preserving the structural integrity of the surrounding frame. The optimization variables correspond to the window thicknesses, whereas the frame dimensions are kept fixed. The dissipative element is connected to a load-transfer system through a mechanism that allows imposed in-plane displacement while preventing axial force transmission, thereby promoting a shear-dominated response. Under cyclic loading, plastic deformation is intended to concentrate in the windows, whereas the frame provides load transfer and stability.
\begin{figure}[!ht] \begin{figure}[!ht]
\centering \centering
\includegraphics[width=0.20\textwidth]{./Figures/Device.png} \includegraphics[width=0.25\textwidth]{./Figures/Device.png}
\caption{Representative BDSL damper configuration analysed in this work. The optimization variables correspond to the window thicknesses, while the surrounding frame dimensions remain fixed. \red{Replace figure with a version including geometric dimensions. Reduce caption.}} \caption{Representative BDSL damper configuration considered in the optimization.}
\label{fig:Device} \label{fig:Device}
\end{figure} \end{figure}
...@@ -110,20 +110,24 @@ The design variables considered in this work are the window thicknesses ...@@ -110,20 +110,24 @@ The design variables considered in this work are the window thicknesses
\mathbf{x}=\left[t_{w,1},t_{w,2},\ldots,t_{w,W}\right], \mathbf{x}=\left[t_{w,1},t_{w,2},\ldots,t_{w,W}\right],
\label{eq:design_vector} \label{eq:design_vector}
\end{equation} \end{equation}
where $W$ denotes the number of windows. The width and height identifiers of the device are represented by $B$ and $H$, respectively. Five geometry families are considered, as shown in Figure \ref{fig:GeometryFamilies}: H30\_B29, H30\_B34, H45\_B29, H45\_B34, and H60\_B34. Devices with $H=30$ cm have two windows, those with $H=45$ cm have three windows, and those with $H=60$ cm have five windows. where $W$ denotes the number of windows. The width and height identifiers of the device are represented by $B$ and $H$, respectively. Five geometry families are considered, as shown in Figure \ref{fig:GeometryFamilies}: H30\_B29, H30\_B34, H45\_B29, H45\_B34 and H60\_B34. Devices with $H=30$ cm have two windows, those with $H=45$ cm have three windows, and those with $H=60$ cm have five windows.
\begin{figure}[ht!] \begin{figure}[ht!]
\centering \centering
\fbox{\parbox[c][0.25\textheight][c]{0.85\textwidth}{\centering Placeholder for geometry family representations.}} \includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth]{Figures/H30_B29.png}\label{fig:H30_B29}
\caption{Geometry families considered in the current implementation.} \includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth]{Figures/H30_B34.png}\label{fig:H30_B34}
\label{fig:GeometryFamilies} \includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth]{Figures/H45_B29.png}\label{fig:H45_B29}
\includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth]{Figures/H45_B34.png}\label{fig:H45_B34}
\includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth]{Figures/H60_B34.png}\label{fig:H60_B34}
\caption{BDSL families considered for optimization in the current study. From left to right: H30\_B29, H30\_B34, H45\_B29, H45\_B34 and H60\_B34.}
\label{fig:GeometryFamilies}
\end{figure} \end{figure}
The admissible thickness ranges are defined according to the geometry family and manufacturing constraints. The main characteristics of each family are summarized in Table~\ref{tab:families}. In all cases, the frame thickness is kept constant at 30 mm. The admissible thickness ranges are defined according to the geometry family and manufacturing constraints. The main characteristics of each family are summarized in Table~\ref{tab:families}. In all cases, the frame thickness is kept constant at 30 mm.
\begin{table}[ht!] \begin{table}[ht!]
\centering \centering
\caption{Geometry families considered in the current implementation and admissible window thickness ranges.} \caption{Geometry families considered for optimization in the current study and admissible window thickness ranges.}
\label{tab:families} \label{tab:families}
\begin{tabular}{lllllll} \begin{tabular}{lllllll}
\toprule \toprule
...@@ -162,19 +166,12 @@ The model was calibrated and validated against cyclic experimental tests perform ...@@ -162,19 +166,12 @@ The model was calibrated and validated against cyclic experimental tests perform
\label{fig:CalibrationCurves} \label{fig:CalibrationCurves}
\end{figure} \end{figure}
Once validated, the FEM model is used to generate the datasets required for surrogate training and optimization. This is essential because the proposed optimization strategy relies on internal response quantities that cannot be directly measured experimentally with sufficient spatial resolution. These quantities include local damage indicators in the dissipative windows and in the surrounding frame, as well as local distortion measures associated with the activation of the dissipative mechanism. Once validated, the FEM model is used to generate the datasets required for surrogate training and optimization. The optimization strategy relies on local damage indicators in the dissipative windows and surrounding frame, together with local distortion measures associated with the activation of the dissipative mechanism. Since these quantities are difficult to measure experimentally with sufficient spatial resolution, the use of a high-fidelity FEM model provides access to the internal state variables and local fields governing damage evolution and energy dissipation.
The main damage indicator adopted in this work is the Triaxial Failure Damage Map (TFDMap) \cite{Rastellini2016}. This stress-triaxiality-based indicator evaluates the proximity of each material point to ductile failure by comparing its stress triaxiality and accumulated equivalent plastic strain with a reference failure envelope \cite{Rice1969,Bao2004,Wierzbicki2005,Bai2008}. In this study, the TFDMap is used as a post-processing damage-screening indicator, not as a constitutive fracture criterion. Its purpose is therefore not to explicitly predict crack initiation, but to compare geometrical configurations and ensure that optimized designs remain within acceptable damage levels. The damage indicator adopted in this work is the Triaxial Failure Damage Map (TFDMap) \cite{Rastellini2016}. This stress-triaxiality-based indicator evaluates the proximity of each material point to ductile failure by comparing its stress triaxiality and accumulated equivalent plastic strain with a reference failure envelope \cite{Rice1969,Bao2004,Wierzbicki2005,Bai2008}. In this study, the TFDMap is used as a post-processing damage-screening indicator, not as a constitutive fracture criterion. Its purpose is therefore not to explicitly predict crack initiation, but to compare geometrical configurations and ensure that optimized designs remain within acceptable damage levels.
For optimization purposes, damage is evaluated separately in the windows and in the frame. The window damage indicator $\TFD_i$ is defined as the average TFDMap value of the 12 nodes with the highest values in window $i$, while the corresponding frame indicator is denoted by $\TFD_f$. This aggregation captures the most critical damage levels while reducing sensitivity to isolated numerical peaks. In addition, the maximum local shear distortion in each window is denoted by $\varepsilon_{xy,i}$ and is used as a proxy for dissipative activation. The contribution of each window is weighted according to its effective geometric volume, so that the optimization accounts not only for point-wise strain values but also for the material volume involved in the dissipation process. For optimization purposes, damage is evaluated separately in the windows and in the frame. The window damage indicator $\TFD_i$ is defined as the average TFDMap value of the 12 nodes with the highest values in window $i$, while the corresponding frame indicator is denoted by $\TFD_f$. This aggregation captures the most critical damage levels while reducing sensitivity to isolated numerical peaks. In addition, the maximum local shear distortion in each window is denoted by $\varepsilon_{xy,i}$ and is used as a proxy for dissipative activation. The contribution of each window is weighted according to its effective geometric volume, so that the optimization accounts not only for point-wise strain values but also for the material volume involved in the dissipation process.
\begin{figure}[ht!]
\centering
\fbox{\parbox[c][0.25\textheight][c]{0.85\textwidth}{\centering Placeholder for an example of the TFDMap and distortion distribution in a device.}}
\caption{Example of TFDMap and local distortion fields used to define the damage and deformation indicators.}
\label{fig:TFDMapDistortion}
\end{figure}
\section{Dataset generation and surrogate modelling}\label{sec:surrogates} \section{Dataset generation and surrogate modelling}\label{sec:surrogates}
\subsection{Design of experiments}\label{subsec:doe} \subsection{Design of experiments}\label{subsec:doe}
...@@ -184,20 +181,20 @@ The FEM campaign is designed to cover the admissible design domain of each devic ...@@ -184,20 +181,20 @@ The FEM campaign is designed to cover the admissible design domain of each devic
To improve the robustness of the surrogate models near the admissible limits, the sampling domain is extended slightly beyond the actual optimization ranges (see Table~\ref{tab:families}). This strategy reduces the risk of extrapolation when evaluating candidate solutions close to the true design limits. The ranges employed during the DoE are summarized in Table~\ref{tab:families_doe}. To improve the robustness of the surrogate models near the admissible limits, the sampling domain is extended slightly beyond the actual optimization ranges (see Table~\ref{tab:families}). This strategy reduces the risk of extrapolation when evaluating candidate solutions close to the true design limits. The ranges employed during the DoE are summarized in Table~\ref{tab:families_doe}.
\begin{table}[ht!] \begin{table}[ht!]
\centering \centering
\caption{Geometry families and window thickness ranges considered during the DoE generation.} \caption{Geometry families and window thickness ranges considered during the DoE generation.}
\label{tab:families_doe} \label{tab:families_doe}
\begin{tabular}{lllllll} \begin{tabular}{lllllll}
\toprule \toprule
Family & Height $H$ & Width $B$ & Windows & Frame thickness & Design variables & Thickness bounds (DoE) \\ Family & Height $H$ & Width $B$ & Windows & Frame thickness & Design variables & Thickness bounds (DoE) \\
\midrule \midrule
H30\_B29 & 30 cm & 29 cm & 2 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2}$ & 8--22 mm \\ H30\_B29 & 30 cm & 29 cm & 2 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2}$ & 8--22 mm \\
H30\_B34 & 30 cm & 34 cm & 2 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2}$ & 8--22 mm \\ H30\_B34 & 30 cm & 34 cm & 2 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2}$ & 8--22 mm \\
H45\_B29 & 45 cm & 29 cm & 3 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2},t_{w,3}$ & 4--16 mm \\ H45\_B29 & 45 cm & 29 cm & 3 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2},t_{w,3}$ & 4--16 mm \\
H45\_B34 & 45 cm & 34 cm & 3 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2},t_{w,3}$ & 4--16 mm \\ H45\_B34 & 45 cm & 34 cm & 3 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},t_{w,2},t_{w,3}$ & 4--16 mm \\
H60\_B34 & 60 cm & 34 cm & 5 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},\ldots,t_{w,5}$ & 4--14 mm \\ H60\_B34 & 60 cm & 34 cm & 5 & 30 mm & $t_{w,1},\ldots,t_{w,5}$ & 4--14 mm \\
\bottomrule \bottomrule
\end{tabular} \end{tabular}
\end{table} \end{table}
For every sampled configuration, a FEM simulation is performed, and the resulting dataset stores both the input variables and the corresponding structural response quantities. The target outputs include the maximum local distortions in each window, denoted by $\varepsilon_{xy,i}$, together with the window damage indicators $\TFD_i$ and the frame damage indicator $\TFD_f$. For every sampled configuration, a FEM simulation is performed, and the resulting dataset stores both the input variables and the corresponding structural response quantities. The target outputs include the maximum local distortions in each window, denoted by $\varepsilon_{xy,i}$, together with the window damage indicators $\TFD_i$ and the frame damage indicator $\TFD_f$.
...@@ -210,11 +207,11 @@ The number of samples in all cases is defined as a power of two. This choice fac ...@@ -210,11 +207,11 @@ The number of samples in all cases is defined as a power of two. This choice fac
\subsection{Supervised ML surrogate models}\label{subsec:ml_models} \subsection{Supervised ML surrogate models}\label{subsec:ml_models}
This work compares several supervised surrogate models for predicting FEM-derived damage and distortion indicators. The considered models cover three families: tree-based methods, including Random Forest (RF) \cite{Breiman2001}, Gradient Boosting Regression (GBR) \cite{Friedman2001}, and XGBoost \cite{Chen2016}; kernel-based methods, including Support Vector Regression (SVR) \cite{Drucker1996} and Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) \cite{Williams1995}; and neural-network models, represented by the Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) \cite{Rosenblatt1958,Rumelhart1986}. RF relies on bootstrap aggregation of decision trees, GBR and XGBoost are sequential boosting approaches, SVR and GPR exploit kernel functions to model nonlinear relationships, and MLP approximates nonlinear input--output mappings through interconnected layers. This work compares several supervised surrogate models for predicting FEM-derived damage and distortion indicators. The considered models cover three families: tree-based methods, including Random Forest (RF) \cite{Breiman2001}, Gradient Boosting Regression (GBR) \cite{Friedman2001} and XGBoost \cite{Chen2016}; kernel-based methods, including Support Vector Regression (SVR) \cite{Drucker1996} and Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) \cite{Williams1995}; and neural-network models, represented by the Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) \cite{Rosenblatt1958,Rumelhart1986}. RF relies on bootstrap aggregation of decision trees, GBR and XGBoost are sequential boosting approaches, SVR and GPR exploit kernel functions to model nonlinear relationships and MLP approximates nonlinear input--output mappings through interconnected layers.
For each geometry family, an independent regression model is trained for every target output. The input vector contains the window thicknesses of the corresponding device, while the outputs are the local distortion indicators $\varepsilon_{xy,i}$, the window damage indicators $\TFD_i$, and the frame damage indicator $\TFD_f$. Therefore, for a device with $W$ windows, $2W+1$ surrogate models are trained: $W$ for distortion, $W$ for window damage, and one for frame damage. For each output, all candidate algorithms are evaluated and the selected model is stored. For each geometry family, an independent regression model is trained for every target output. The input vector contains the window thicknesses of the corresponding device, while the outputs are the local distortion indicators $\varepsilon_{xy,i}$, the window damage indicators $\TFD_i$ and the frame damage indicator $\TFD_f$. Therefore, for a device with $W$ windows, $2W+1$ surrogate models are trained: $W$ for distortion, $W$ for window damage and one for frame damage. For each output, all candidate algorithms are evaluated and the selected model is stored.
Hyperparameters are optimized using Bayesian optimization \cite{Snoek2012}, with 40 evaluations per model. The first 10 evaluations are randomly sampled to explore the search space, while the remaining 30 are guided by the Bayesian surrogate model. This strategy provides a more efficient alternative to exhaustive grid search, particularly given the number of geometry families, target outputs, and candidate algorithms considered. Hyperparameters are optimized using Bayesian optimization \cite{Snoek2012}, with 40 evaluations per model. The first 10 evaluations are randomly sampled to explore the search space, while the remaining 30 are guided by the Bayesian surrogate model. This strategy provides a more efficient alternative to exhaustive grid search, particularly given the number of geometry families, target outputs and candidate algorithms considered.
The cross-validation strategy is adapted to the dataset size. Leave-One-Out validation is used for $N\leq20$, repeated five-fold cross-validation with five repetitions for $21\leq N\leq80$, and shuffled five-fold cross-validation for larger datasets. For small datasets, the search spaces of tree-based models are restricted to reduce overfitting. The cross-validation strategy is adapted to the dataset size. Leave-One-Out validation is used for $N\leq20$, repeated five-fold cross-validation with five repetitions for $21\leq N\leq80$, and shuffled five-fold cross-validation for larger datasets. For small datasets, the search spaces of tree-based models are restricted to reduce overfitting.
......
Markdown is supported
0% or
You are about to add 0 people to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Please register or to comment